profile evaluation - emerging markets PE

Free advice from the world's top MBA consultants
This topic has expert replies
Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu May 05, 2011 12:03 am

profile evaluation - emerging markets PE

by PE Guy » Fri May 06, 2011 7:01 am
I was wondering what you all thought about my chances to get into HBS, Stanford and Wharton. My impression would be that I've got a very solid chance of getting accepted at Columbia, MIT, U-Chicago, etc, but that I might have some trouble going up against the superstars fighting for spots at HBS and Stanford.

UG: Dartmouth/Cornell/Brown w/ 3.50 GPA majors IR & Chinese. Studied abroad at Tsinghua (best uni in china) and had excellent internships in technology and consulting during UG.

GMAT: 730, skewed towards verbal, but still respectable in Q

Work Experience:

(1) after graduating in 2008, I spent 3 months as summer analyst at best in class real estate private equity and development firm in London. I got great training and traveled extensively throughout Europe. This firm, unlike the majority of my experience, has a well respected name (think Carlyle Group)

(2) After London I moved to Beijing/Shanghai, where I live now. I've been here almost 3 years now, working at a small private equity firm focused on making investments in real estate throughout mainland China. I've executed deals across the country and become fluent (or very close) in mandarin Chinese (I'm a white guy). I was promoted from analyst to associate after 2 years. THE ONLY TWO PROBLEMS WITH THIS EXPERIENCE are that (a) our firm is new and essentially unknown in the U.S. even though it's owned by U.S. citizens (b) while we've had some success and are growing, we still have small AUM of under 200m which admittedly could be considered "bush league".

EXTRA CURRICULAR / Leadership:

(1) actively involved in my Uni's club here in China (no formal position, but I could get one if I asked) and I am also a counselor to the kids who come over and study abroad in China in the program. I am in close contact with all the profs etc.

(2) basically nothing else... but i could add something if need be. I have plenty of money and resources around... the problem is I want to apply in 5 months time.

Anyways, sorry for the long winded post, but I wanted to give you the best possible outline of my profile. The central question is HOW IMPORTANT is the NAME RECOGNITION of the firm where you work? Ostensibly working in PE in China is about the best possible pre-mba experience you could ask for... but I'm afraid that the size / relatively lack of prestige of my firm might destroy my chances.

Thanks,
Source: — Ask an MBA Admissions Consultant |

User avatar
Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
Posts: 368
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 3:18 pm
Location: Los Angeles CA
Thanked: 30 times
Followed by:13 members

by Linda Abraham » Thu May 26, 2011 4:01 pm
PE Guy wrote:I was wondering what you all thought about my chances to get into HBS, Stanford and Wharton. My impression would be that I've got a very solid chance of getting accepted at Columbia, MIT, U-Chicago, etc, but that I might have some trouble going up against the superstars fighting for spots at HBS and Stanford.

UG: Dartmouth/Cornell/Brown w/ 3.50 GPA majors IR & Chinese. Studied abroad at Tsinghua (best uni in china) and had excellent internships in technology and consulting during UG.

GMAT: 730, skewed towards verbal, but still respectable in Q

Work Experience:

(1) after graduating in 2008, I spent 3 months as summer analyst at best in class real estate private equity and development firm in London. I got great training and traveled extensively throughout Europe. This firm, unlike the majority of my experience, has a well respected name (think Carlyle Group)

(2) After London I moved to Beijing/Shanghai, where I live now. I've been here almost 3 years now, working at a small private equity firm focused on making investments in real estate throughout mainland China. I've executed deals across the country and become fluent (or very close) in mandarin Chinese (I'm a white guy). I was promoted from analyst to associate after 2 years. THE ONLY TWO PROBLEMS WITH THIS EXPERIENCE are that (a) our firm is new and essentially unknown in the U.S. even though it's owned by U.S. citizens (b) while we've had some success and are growing, we still have small AUM of under 200m which admittedly could be considered "bush league".

EXTRA CURRICULAR / Leadership:

(1) actively involved in my Uni's club here in China (no formal position, but I could get one if I asked) and I am also a counselor to the kids who come over and study abroad in China in the program. I am in close contact with all the profs etc.

(2) basically nothing else... but i could add something if need be. I have plenty of money and resources around... the problem is I want to apply in 5 months time.

Anyways, sorry for the long winded post, but I wanted to give you the best possible outline of my profile. The central question is HOW IMPORTANT is the NAME RECOGNITION of the firm where you work? Ostensibly working in PE in China is about the best possible pre-mba experience you could ask for... but I'm afraid that the size / relatively lack of prestige of my firm might destroy my chances.

Best,
Linda

Thanks,
I'm really sorry it has taken us so long to respond.

I believe you would be a competitive applicant at HBS, Stanford and Wharton. You will need to educate them a little about what you have done, which would be less important with a name firm, but your experience sounds excellent to me. The relative size and lack of prestige of your firm is not going to be a big deal if you really accomplished something while working for it.

I do encourage you to assume an official role or responsibility on the community service area if you can't take responsibility for the informal role you have played or for any specific projects or initiatives. You been involved for X years and your involvement will culminate with the project X.

If you need help with your MBA applications, please keep Accepted in mind.
Linda Abraham
Accepted.com -- Helping You Write Your Best!
310.815.9553
Accepted Blog
Accepted on Twitter
Accepted on Facebook