Statement 1:
1) Substitute X = 1/2 gives us Y = + SQRT(10/3) , - SQRT (10/3)
Which will tell us Y is not equal to 1 , Which is sufficient
2) Substitute X = 1/2 gives us Y = 1 ( exactly ) which is sufficient to answer
Hence D be the answer in my point of view, Please let me know how it got B as answer
is Y equal to 1
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |

















