BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Lofgren’s disease

Expert replies
by geet » Sat Jul 18, 2009 5:00 am
Lofgren’s disease has been observed frequently in commercially raised cattle but very rarely in chickens. Both cattle and chickens raised for meat are often fed the type of feed that transmits the virus that causes the disease. Animals infected with the virus take more than a year to develop symptoms of Lofgren’s disease, however, and chickens commercially raised for meat, unlike cattle, are generally brought to market during their first year of life.

Which of the following is most strongly supported by the information provided?

A. The virus that causes Lofgren’s disease cannot be transmitted to human beings by chickens.
B. There is no way to determine whether a chicken is infected with the Lofgren’s disease virus before the chicken shows symptoms of the disease.
C. A failure to observe Lofgren’s disease in commercial chicken populations is not good evidence that chickens are immune to the virus that causes this disease.
D. An animal that has been infected with the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease but that has not developed symptoms cannot transmit the disease to an uninfected animal of the same species.
E. The feed that chickens and cattle are fed is probably not the only source of the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease.
Join the discussion
Source: — Critical Reasoning |

by gmat740 » Sat Jul 18, 2009 6:24 am
B & C are close
IMO-C
A. The virus that causes Lofgren’s disease cannot be transmitted to human beings by chickens. Only symptoms are not observed, nowhere in the argument transmission of the disease is mentioned

B. There is no way to determine whether a chicken is infected with the Lofgren’s disease virus before the chicken shows symptoms of the disease. This is close but it goes to the extreme.We must remember chickens do show symptoms RARELY
C. A failure to observe Lofgren’s disease in commercial chicken populations is not good evidence that chickens are immune to the virus that causes this disease. correct
D. An animal that has been infected with the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease but that has not developed symptoms cannot transmit the disease to an uninfected animal of the same species. Virus is there but it is not developed, but that does not mean that the disease can
t be transmitted

E. The feed that chickens and cattle are fed is probably not the only source of the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease.out of scope
Hope this Helps
Join the discussion

by pandeyvineet24 » Sat Jul 18, 2009 7:10 am
C it is
B is too extreme " ...No way..."
Others are out of scope.
Join the discussion

by ranell » Sat Jul 18, 2009 8:34 am
A. The virus that causes Lofgren’s disease cannot be transmitted to human beings by chickens. – whether the virus can or cannot be transmitted to human beings is out of scope
B. There is no way to determine whether a chicken is infected with the Lofgren’s disease virus before the chicken shows symptoms of the disease. – the argument is not about any ways to determine whether a chicken is infected or not
C. A failure to observe Lofgren’s disease in commercial chicken populations is not good evidence that chickens are immune to the virus that causes this disease. – CORRECT as according to the argument chickens are generally brought to market during their first year of life and thus there is not enough time for them to develop symptoms of the disease
D. An animal that has been infected with the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease but that has not developed symptoms cannot transmit the disease to an uninfected animal of the same species. – it is not supported by the argument
E. The feed that chickens and cattle are fed is probably not the only source of the virus that causes Lofgren’s disease. – the types of feed that causes the disease are out of scope in the argument.
Join the discussion

by mehravikas » Sun Jul 19, 2009 5:28 pm
Confused between C and D...!!
Join the discussion

by geet » Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:23 pm
OA is C
Join the discussion

by maihuna » Sun Sep 20, 2009 4:38 am
geet wrote:OA is C
I think the OA is controversial. Any one else attempting on this.
Charged up again to beat the beast :)
Join the discussion

by sanp_l » Sun Sep 20, 2009 5:16 am
The confusion is clearly between Option C and Option B.

That there is no way to determine whether a chicken is infected or not by the virus before the chicken shows any symptoms as the passage doesnt hint that. There might be some other ways which aren't in the scope.
Additionlly commercial chickens are brought to market in a year and as the time it takes for the symptoms to surface is more than an year, the point is certainly not a good evidence.The passage clearly says many are brought in a year to the market and the first line says rarely is the virus seen. hence Option C stands correct.
I go with Option C.
Sandy
Join the discussion

by kris77 » Sun May 15, 2016 4:15 pm
I feel the answer will be C
Join the discussion