Work rate problem, tricky one

Question

From an MGMAT CAT

Machine A can complete a certain job in x hours. Machine B can complete the same job in y hours. If A and B work together at their respective rates to complete the job, which of the following represents the fraction of the job that B will not have to complete?

A) (x-y) / (x+y)

B) x / (y-x)

C) (x+y) / xy

D) y / (x-y)

E) y / (x+y)

OA: E

The MGMAT explains the problem by using the VIC method (plugging in numbers) which seems ridiculously time consuming.

Can someone demonstrate the solution using standard x and y work equations? Thanks.

saketk · Answer

razorback wrote:From an MGMAT CAT

Machine A can complete a certain job in x hours. Machine B can complete the same job in y hours. If A and B work together at their respective rates to complete the job, which of the following represents the fraction of the job that B will not have to complete?

A) (x-y) / (x+y)

B) x / (y-x)

C) (x+y) / xy

D) y / (x-y)

E) y / (x+y)

OA: E

The MGMAT explains the problem by using the VIC method (plugging in numbers) which seems ridiculously time consuming.

Can someone demonstrate the solution using standard x and y work equations? Thanks.

Why do you think that plugging in the numbers would take more time?

If you replace x by 2 and y by 3 and solve this question then it will not take more than 60 secs to solve this.

Method 1: -

X= 2
Y= 3

Total time taken when A and B work together -

(3*2)/(3+2) = 6/5 hrs

Time taken by B alone = 3 hrs. i.e. in 1 hr work done = 1/3

So, work done in 6/5 hrs = 2/5
Work not done by B = 1-2/5 = 3/5

Put X =2 and Y=3 in the option and see which expression gives you 3/5

Correct answer OPTION E

saketk · Answer

Method 2: -

Time taken when A and B work together = xy/(x+y)

in 1 hr B does 1/y work

so, in xy/(x+y) hrs work done by B = 1/y* [xy/(x+y)] = x/(x+y)

So, work not done by B = 1- [x/(x+y)] = y/(x+y)

OPTION E

fcabanski · Answer

That's a simple problem, and plugging in numbers takes less time.

user123321 · Answer

A does 1/x work in 1 hr
B does 1/y work in 1 hr
Both does 1/x+1/y work in 1 hr or they take xy/(x+y) hrs to do 1 work

the fraction of work B will not complete if they do together is ...(1/x+1/y-1/y) = 1/x in 1 hr
But in xy/(x+y) hrs it will be (1/x).(xy/(x+y)) = y/(x+y)

user123321

Just started my preparation

Want to do it right the first time.

Anurag@Gurome · Answer

razorback wrote:From an MGMAT CAT

Machine A can complete a certain job in x hours. Machine B can complete the same job in y hours. If A and B work together at their respective rates to complete the job, which of the following represents the fraction of the job that B will not have to complete?

A) (x-y) / (x+y)

B) x / (y-x)

C) (x+y) / xy

D) y / (x-y)

E) y / (x+y)

OA: E

The MGMAT explains the problem by using the VIC method (plugging in numbers) which seems ridiculously time consuming.

Can someone demonstrate the solution using standard x and y work equations? Thanks.

Why do you think that plugging in the numbers would take more time?

If you replace x by 2 and y by 3 and solve this question then it will not take more than 60 secs to solve this.

Method 1: -

X= 2
Y= 3

Total time taken when A and B work together -

(3*2)/(3+2) = 6/5 hrs

Time taken by B alone = 3 hrs. i.e. in 1 hr work done = 1/3

So, work done in 6/5 hrs = 2/5
Work not done by B = 1-2/5 = 3/5

Put X =2 and Y=3 in the option and see which expression gives you 3/5

Correct answer OPTION E

Choose how you want to prepare

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

Work rate problem, tricky one

GMAT/MBA Expert

Chicago Booth

GMAT Course Reviews

Admissions Consulting Reviews

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

GMAT PREP DEAL TRACKER