Live GMAT classes with Target Test Prep start Nov 21 and Nov 22. First class free.

See classes
Target Test Prep · GMAT

Choose how you want to prepare

Learn live with an expert or move at your own pace. Every option includes the complete TTP study system.

Newsweek Readers’ Choice Awards 2026 winner: Target Test Prep, #1 Test Prep

Target Test Prep was voted #1 Best Test Prep in the 2026 Newsweek Readers’ Choice™ Awards.

★★★★★5.0563 reviews
GMATLiveTeachStarts Nov 22
Josh Braslow, Target Test Prep GMAT expert
LIVE ONLINE CLASSES

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

with Josh Braslow, 20+ years in test prep

Nov 22 · Josh Braslow
Sun · 9:30 AM to 12:30 PM ET
Included
40 hours of live online classes + 6 months of TTP OnDemand
  • Attend the first class for free
  • Every class is recorded, so you never fall behind
View classes & enroll
Limited seats availableTarget Test Prep
EALiveTeachOnDemandStart anytime
EXECUTIVE ASSESSMENT

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Self-paced EA prep. Study on your schedule.

EXECUTIVE ASSESSMENT

with

165+ EA score guarantee
$05-day trial no automatic billing
Schedule
Included
40 hours of live online classes plus six months of access to the complete TTP EA OnDemand course.
  • 165+ EA Score Guarantee
  • 4,100+ Quant, Verbal, and Integrated Reasoning practice questions
  • 400+ hours of in-depth video lessons
  • 3,000+ step-by-step video solutions
View EA class & enroll Start free 5-day trial
Limited cohort · enrollment openTrial includes full course accessTarget Test Prep
GMATOnDemandStart anytime
SELF-PACED MASTERCLASS

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

Complete access from day one. Study on your schedule.

715+ score guarantee
$0to start then $127/mo
  • Personalized study plan and analytics
  • Thousands of lessons and practice questions

Visitors saw Monkeys !!!

Expert replies
by goelmohit2002 » Fri May 15, 2009 12:00 am
Hi All,

Below is the question from OG-10 (Q113).

Visitors to the park have often looked up into the leafy canopy and saw monkeys sleeping on the branches, whose arms and legs hang like socks on a clothesline.

Apart from "saw" reason, the reason for kicking out this option as given by OG is "Choices A, B, and E awkwardly separate the relative clause beginning whose arms and legs ... from monkeys, the noun it modifies"

Can somebody please help me understand why it is wrong to separate the same. As per my understanding who/whose modifies people/animals. So it should clearly modify the Monkeys.

Can who/whose refer to all sorts of living things too..for e.g. including plants/trees ec... ? If yes, probably whose can modify the living things(Branches in the above sentence). Please help me understand the same.

If say who/whose can modify all sort of living things....then will it still be problematic if the sentence would have been like:

Visitors saw monkeys sleeping on the table, whose arms and legs hang like socks on a clothesline.

In the above sentence "whose" will modify monkeys or not ?

Kindly tell what I am missing here.

Thanks
Mohit
Join the discussion
Source: — Sentence Correction |

by Vitalina » Fri May 15, 2009 12:25 am
IMO:
'..branches, whose ..' modifies branches, as it comes right after this word, thus it is incorrect.
whose should come directly after monkeys to make the sentence correct, or modifier should be expressed with words like 'with armsand legs hanging...'

That's what I think :)
Join the discussion

by goelmohit2002 » Fri May 15, 2009 12:35 am
IMO it is not as simple as that...there is something more to this. Please see the below sentence from Modifier chapter of Manhattan:

Cars come in various colors, which can be cool and trendy.

Here Manhattan says that which makes the above sentence ambigous...as which can modify colors as well as cars...if the touch rule is there...they why it does not apply here.

I am also puzzled by this Modifier rule :-)
Join the discussion

by rookiez » Fri May 15, 2009 1:10 am
In the original sentence whose refer to branch (immediate antecedent). But if we see the next part after whose in the sentence, branches cannot have arms and legs, so the modifying clause is wrong here.
Join the discussion

by goelmohit2002 » Fri May 15, 2009 1:34 am
rookiez wrote:In the original sentence whose refer to branch (immediate antecedent). But if we see the next part after whose in the sentence, branches cannot have arms and legs, so the modifying clause is wrong here.
Can you please help me understand why the same touch rule does apply here too:

Cars come in various colors, which can be cool and trendy.

Here Manhattan says that which makes the above sentence ambigous...as which can modify colors as well as cars...if the touch rule is there...they why it does not apply here.
Join the discussion

by bluementor » Sat May 16, 2009 4:43 am
goelmohit2002 wrote:
rookiez wrote:In the original sentence whose refer to branch (immediate antecedent). But if we see the next part after whose in the sentence, branches cannot have arms and legs, so the modifying clause is wrong here.
Can you please help me understand why the same touch rule does apply here too:

Cars come in various colors, which can be cool and trendy.

Here Manhattan says that which makes the above sentence ambigous...as which can modify colors as well as cars...if the touch rule is there...they why it does not apply here.
I believe you are using either the 2005 or the 2007 edition of MGMAT SC. In my opinion, the explanation that "...the sentence is ambigous.." is not really correct (I know a lot of people swear by it). MGMAT 3rd edition has the following rule, which I believe is correct:

A Noun and its Modifier should Touch each other.


So in other words, in MGMAT's example on cars, the relative clause modifies colors by default., and not cars. No ambiguity here, it's just wrong because it doesnt make sense.

In the original SC problem posted above, the whose clause modifies branches by default, and thats the reason why this choice is not correct, as correctly explained by Vitalina and rookiez.

--------------------------------

**I personally came across a lot of issues with the 2007 ed. of MGMAT SC, where I found some rules (Possesive Poison is one such rule that comes to mind) that doesn't clearly explain some of the problems that you see in the OG. The 3rd edition, on the other hand, is on a whole new level. It has not only better explanation for these rules, but also in-depth explanation of the nuances/exceptions to these rules.

-BM-
Join the discussion

by iamcste » Sat May 16, 2009 5:36 am
Yes! Whose can refer to people or things hence it can refer to branches as well the monkeys and mar the intended meaning

In correct answer, clause starting with whose is replaced with a phrase starting "with".

Can you pls post the complete qtn and then put your specific doubts. Many people do not have OG all the time with them..
Join the discussion

by goelmohit2002 » Sat May 16, 2009 8:17 am
iamcste wrote:Yes! Whose can refer to people or things hence it can refer to branches as well the monkeys and mar the intended meaning

In correct answer, clause starting with whose is replaced with a phrase starting "with".

Can you pls post the complete qtn and then put your specific doubts. Many people do not have OG all the time with them..
Thanks for clarifying....The complete question is as follows:

Visitors to the park have often looked up into the leafy canopy and saw monkeys sleeping on the branches, whose arms and legs hang like socks on a clothesline.
(A) saw monkeys sleeping on the branches, whose arms and legs hang
(B) saw monkeys sleeping on the branches, whose arms and legs were hanging
(C) saw monkeys sleeping on the branches, with arms and legs hanging
(D) seen monkeys sleeping on the branches, with arms and legs hanging
(E) seen monkeys sleeping on the branches, whose arms and legs have hung

Thanks
Mohit
Join the discussion

by Stacey Koprince » Wed May 20, 2009 11:32 am
Received a PM asking me to respond. Generally speaking, noun modifiers should touch the nouns they modify. There are some very rare exceptions to the rule (it seems like there are always rare exceptions to every grammar rule, doesn't it? :)) - but for the most part, they should touch.

who (or whose) indicates a noun modifier, and when we see a "comma who" (or "comma whose") setup, the noun before the comma should be the noun that is being modified.

In the car sentence example, there is something a bit more complicated going on. From a technical standpoint, "which can be cool and trendy" modifies colors, the noun preceding the comma. But we could also describe cars as "cool and trendy" right? The explanation in the old book probably could've elaborated a bit more, but the idea is: if someone says this sentence, do you know whether the person is trying to say "cars can be cool and trendy" or "colors can be cool and trendy"? I wouldn't really be sure, unless I knew the person was a total grammar nut and would make sure to construct anything they say perfectly correctly. So, in that sense, it's ambiguous, and that's why we have to be careful about how we construct these things. But, as far as strict grammar is concerned, the sentence is saying "colors can be cool and trendy."

By the same token, in the OG problem here (which I'm only going to mention VERY briefly, because we're not supposed to discuss OG problems online!), the "comma whose" answers point to the word before the comma, but that word doesn't make sense... so those choices are all wrong. A "comma preposition" set-up, however, is more loose - it's not a strict noun modifier and doesn't have to modify only the noun immediately preceding the comma. It can modify the whole clause. So "comma with" is the way to go on this one.
Please note: I do not use the Private Messaging system! I will not see any PMs that you send to me!!

Stacey Koprince
GMAT Instructor
Director of Online Community
Manhattan GMAT

Contributor to Beat The GMAT!

Learn more about me
Join the discussion