• NEW! FREE Beat The GMAT Quizzes
Hundreds of Questions Highly Detailed Reporting Expert Explanations
• 7 CATs FREE!
If you earn 100 Forum Points

Engage in the Beat The GMAT forums to earn
100 points for $49 worth of Veritas practice GMATs FREE VERITAS PRACTICE GMAT EXAMS Earn 10 Points Per Post Earn 10 Points Per Thanks Earn 10 Points Per Upvote ## The beautiful cello solo at the end of the symphony may have ##### This topic has 2 expert replies and 4 member replies ## The beautiful cello solo at the end of the symphony may have The beautiful cello solo at the end of the symphony may have salvaged the performance, for most of the orchestra members performed poorly throughout the two hour concert. A- for most of the orchestra members performed poorly throughout the two hour concert. B- in that most of the orchestra members performed throughout the two hour concert in a poor manner. C- when most of the orchestra members performed poorly throughout the two hour concert. D- despite most of the orchestra members performing poorly throughout the two hour concert. E- Even though most of the orchestra members made a poor performance throughout the two hour concert. OA is A I completely agree with the OA, as it is answering "why the beautiful solo may have salvaged"; however, i don't understand D. If i change D to - despite the poor performance by most of the orchestra members throughout the two hour concert, the beautiful cello at the end of the symphony may have salvaged the performance Is this sentence correct now ? Can anyone please tell me how to eliminate D ? Thanks ### Top Member Legendary Member Joined 03 Feb 2014 Posted: 2070 messages Followed by: 133 members Upvotes: 955 GMAT Score: 800 vinni.k wrote: I completely agree with the OA, as it is answering "why the beautiful solo may have salvaged"; however, i don't understand D. If i change D to - despite the poor performance by most of the orchestra members throughout the two hour concert, the beautiful cello at the end of the symphony may have salvaged the performance Is this sentence correct now ? Can anyone please tell me how to eliminate D ? Thanks It is the opinion of many, but not all, writers that the noun that represents the agent of the action described by a gerund should be in the possessive form. So "members performing poorly" ideally would be instead "members' performing poorly". At the same time, I don't think that that issue is what the creator of this question had in mind as the reason to eliminate D, and other than that issue I don't see any real reason to eliminate D. This question isn't great. Probably you should just learn what you can from it and not worry too much about eliminating D. _________________ Marty Murray GMAT Coach m.w.murray@hotmail.com https://infinitemindprep.com/ In Person in the New York Area and Online Worldwide ### GMAT/MBA Expert GMAT Instructor Joined 04 Dec 2012 Posted: 2047 messages Followed by: 238 members Upvotes: 1443 vinni.k wrote: I completely agree with the OA, as it is answering "why the beautiful solo may have salvaged"; however, i don't understand D. If i change D to - despite the poor performance by most of the orchestra members throughout the two hour concert, the beautiful cello at the end of the symphony may have salvaged the performance Is this sentence correct now ? Can anyone please tell me how to eliminate D ? Thanks Contrast words such as DESPITE or EVEN THOUGH wouldn't make sense in this context. The word SALVAGE implies that things were otherwise going badly, but the cello solo fixed it. We wouldn't then put a contrast word between the "salvaging" and the "performing badly." Consider: I saved your life, even though you were going to die. This doesn't make sense. The only condition under which it's possible to save your life is if you were going to die, so there is no contrast possible between these two ideas. It only makes sense to say one of the following: I saved your life because you were going to die. I saved your life when you were going to die. I saved your life for you were going to die. Does that help? _________________ Ceilidh Erickson Manhattan Prep GMAT & GRE instructor EdM in Mind, Brain, and Education Harvard Graduate School of Education Manhattan Prep instructors all have 99th+ percentile scores and expert teaching experience. Sign up for a FREE TRIAL, and learn why we have the highest ratings in the GMAT industry! Free Manhattan Prep online events - The first class of every online Manhattan Prep course is free. Classes start every week. ### Top Member Legendary Member Joined 03 Feb 2014 Posted: 2070 messages Followed by: 133 members Upvotes: 955 GMAT Score: 800 ceilidh.erickson wrote: vinni.k wrote: Can anyone please tell me how to eliminate D ? Thanks Contrast words such as DESPITE or EVEN THOUGH wouldn't make sense in this context. The word SALVAGE implies that things were otherwise going badly, but the cello solo fixed it. We wouldn't then put a contrast word between the "salvaging" and the "performing badly." Consider: I saved your life, even though you were going to die. This doesn't make sense. The only condition under which it's possible to save your life is if you were going to die, so there is no contrast possible between these two ideas. It only makes sense to say one of the following: I saved your life because you were going to die. I saved your life when you were going to die. I saved your life for you were going to die. Does that help? What about the following? I saved your life, even though you didn't take care of yourself for most of the last twenty years. Notice, the sentence is not Despite the performance not being salvaged, the cello solo may have salvaged the performance. The sentence says basically Despite the fact that most of the members of the orchestra performed poorly throughout the entire concert, that great cello solo may have salvaged the performance. which makes sense, as does the following. Even though most of the musicians did a terrible job for the entire two hours, the cello solo may have been enough to salvage the performance. Meawhile, "for" basically means "because" or possibly "as". So A is not great either. This does not really make sense. Because most of the members of the orchestra performed poorly for the entire concert, the cello solo at the end may have salvaged the performance. "As" is a little better, though even when "as" is used, the point of the sentence is still not entirely clear. The beautiful cello solo at the end of the symphony may have salvaged the performance, as most of the orchestra members performed poorly throughout the two hour concert. Possibly the point is meant to be the following. As most of the members of the orchestra performed poorly throughout the entire two hour concert, the beautiful cello solo at the end of the symphony was the only thing that salvaged the performance. Still, I am liking "despite" better with each attempt to torture the sentence into making "for" or "as" work. So while this question proved to be a great conversation piece, and while noticing the difference between "despite" and "for" is useful, this question is not very tight. _________________ Marty Murray GMAT Coach m.w.murray@hotmail.com https://infinitemindprep.com/ In Person in the New York Area and Online Worldwide ### GMAT/MBA Expert GMAT Instructor Joined 04 Dec 2012 Posted: 2047 messages Followed by: 238 members Upvotes: 1443 I'll definitely agree with you that this isn't a very good question! I take your point, and "as" is a much better option than "for" or "despite," though I find that GMAT questions that deal with contrast words such as "despite" usually are much more clear about the contrast presented. I doubt we'd see a "despite" in a right answer on a similar question. But... mostly I doubt that we'd see this question at all! On the real GMAT, you (probably) won't find questions like this, on which even the experts disagree about subtle differences in meaning. Feel free to ignore this one. _________________ Ceilidh Erickson Manhattan Prep GMAT & GRE instructor EdM in Mind, Brain, and Education Harvard Graduate School of Education Manhattan Prep instructors all have 99th+ percentile scores and expert teaching experience. Sign up for a FREE TRIAL, and learn why we have the highest ratings in the GMAT industry! Free Manhattan Prep online events - The first class of every online Manhattan Prep course is free. Classes start every week. ### Top Member Legendary Member Joined 03 Feb 2014 Posted: 2070 messages Followed by: 133 members Upvotes: 955 GMAT Score: 800 ceilidh.erickson wrote: I'll definitely agree with you that this isn't a very good question! I take your point, and "as" is a much better option than "for" or "despite," though I find that GMAT questions that deal with contrast words such as "despite" usually are much more clear about the contrast presented. Makes sense. _________________ Marty Murray GMAT Coach m.w.murray@hotmail.com https://infinitemindprep.com/ In Person in the New York Area and Online Worldwide Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts Joined 17 Apr 2011 Posted: 421 messages Followed by: 2 members Upvotes: 6 Test Date: 2016 Target GMAT Score: 700+ GMAT Score: 620 Marty and ceilidh, Thank you for clearing the doubt. • FREE GMAT Exam Know how you'd score today for$0

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Award-winning private GMAT tutoring
Register now and save up to \$200

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Free Veritas GMAT Class
Experience Lesson 1 Live Free

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Free Trial & Practice Exam
BEAT THE GMAT EXCLUSIVE

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• 1 Hour Free
BEAT THE GMAT EXCLUSIVE

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Get 300+ Practice Questions

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Free Practice Test & Review
How would you score if you took the GMAT

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• Magoosh
Study with Magoosh GMAT prep

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• 5 Day FREE Trial
Study Smarter, Not Harder

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

• 5-Day Free Trial
5-day free, full-access trial TTP Quant

Available with Beat the GMAT members only code

### Top First Responders*

1 Jay@ManhattanReview 69 first replies
2 Brent@GMATPrepNow 66 first replies
3 GMATGuruNY 42 first replies
4 Ian Stewart 25 first replies
5 Scott@TargetTestPrep 15 first replies
* Only counts replies to topics started in last 30 days
See More Top Beat The GMAT Members

### Most Active Experts

1 Scott@TargetTestPrep

Target Test Prep

200 posts
2 Brent@GMATPrepNow

GMAT Prep Now Teacher

92 posts
3 Max@Math Revolution

Math Revolution

91 posts
4 Jay@ManhattanReview

Manhattan Review

76 posts
5 GMATGuruNY

The Princeton Review Teacher

64 posts
See More Top Beat The GMAT Experts