Hi All,
There's actually a rather simple way to deal with this issue. Focus on what the prompt GIVES YOU to work with.
If you're given a square root sign, then you are responsible for the POSITIVE answer ONLY.
If you're given a squared term (e.g. X^2 = 25), then you are responsible for BOTH the POSITIVE and NEGATIVE answers.
By extension, if you're given a quadratic (e.g. X^2 +2X - 3), then you're responsible for BOTH answers (regardless of whether they're positive or negative).
In questions involving logical restrictions (geometry, etc.), there's no such thing as a "negative side length", which is why the Pythagorean Theorem is concerned with just the positive results.
GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich