Q is a set of integers and 11 is in Q. Let q (small q) denote any element in the Q set. Is every positive multiple of 11 in Q?
1 q+11 is in Q
2 q11 is in Q
Answer: 1 Statement 1 is sufficient, but statment 2 is not sufficient
Thanks! If anyone has time, please explain the answer thoroughly becuase I am having trouble understanding it.
Set integer/multiple of Q
 milanproda
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 58
 Joined: 25 Sep 2010
 Location: Belgrade, Serbia/ New York, USA
 Thanked: 1 times
GMAT/MBA Expert
 Anurag@Gurome
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 3835
 Joined: 02 Apr 2010
 Location: Milpitas, CA
 Thanked: 1854 times
 Followed by:523 members
 GMAT Score:770
Given: Q is a set of integers and 11 is in Q.milanproda wrote:Q is a set of integers and 11 is in Q. Let q (small q) denote any element in the Q set. Is every positive multiple of 11 in Q?
1 q+11 is in Q
2 q11 is in Q
Now q denote any element in the Q set. Note that this means any element of set Q can be taken as q.
Statement 1: (q + 11) is in Q
We know that 11 is in set Q. Therefore we can say q = 11. This implies (q + 11) = 22 is in Q. Now we can say q = 22, thus (q + 11) = 33 is in Q. Thus 44, 55, 66 etc all are in Q. Which means all positive multiples of 11 are in Q.
Sufficient
Statement 2: (q  11) is in Q
We know that 11 is in set Q. Therefore we can say q = 11. This implies (q  11) = 0 is in Q. Now we can say q = 0, thus (q  11) = 11 is in Q. Thus 22, 33, 44 etc all are in Q. Which means all nonpositive multiples of 11 are in Q. But nothing can be said about positive multiples of 11.
Not sufficient
The correct answer is A.
Anurag Mairal, Ph.D., MBA
GMAT Expert, Admissions and Career Guidance
Gurome, Inc.
18005664043 (USA)
Join Our Facebook Groups
GMAT with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/272466352793633/
Admissions with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/461459690536574/
Career Advising with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/360435787349781/
GMAT Expert, Admissions and Career Guidance
Gurome, Inc.
18005664043 (USA)
Join Our Facebook Groups
GMAT with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/272466352793633/
Admissions with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/461459690536574/
Career Advising with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/360435787349781/
 milanproda
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 58
 Joined: 25 Sep 2010
 Location: Belgrade, Serbia/ New York, USA
 Thanked: 1 times
Thanks!
I had trouble understanding what the question wanted, and I did not realize that I should substitute 11 as q, which was my biggest fault.
For arguements sake, because the question said that q can denote any element in Q set, could I assume that any positive integer is in Q set? Or does the 1st stem indicate that it must be a multiple of 11?
I had trouble understanding what the question wanted, and I did not realize that I should substitute 11 as q, which was my biggest fault.
For arguements sake, because the question said that q can denote any element in Q set, could I assume that any positive integer is in Q set? Or does the 1st stem indicate that it must be a multiple of 11?
Milan Prodanovic
milanproda@gmail.com
milanproda@gmail.com
hi Anurag
honestly did not get nether problem nor your explanation,
q can be any any element in Q, and the terms in set Q are not specified
q=1, q+11=1+11=12 is not multiple of 11
q=11, 11+11=22 multiple of 11
deeply confused....?
honestly did not get nether problem nor your explanation,
q can be any any element in Q, and the terms in set Q are not specified
q=1, q+11=1+11=12 is not multiple of 11
q=11, 11+11=22 multiple of 11
deeply confused....?
 milanproda
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 58
 Joined: 25 Sep 2010
 Location: Belgrade, Serbia/ New York, USA
 Thanked: 1 times
GMAT/MBA Expert
 Anurag@Gurome
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 3835
 Joined: 02 Apr 2010
 Location: Milpitas, CA
 Thanked: 1854 times
 Followed by:523 members
 GMAT Score:770
Yes, there may or may not be other integers in set Q.clock60 wrote:hi Anurag
honestly did not get nether problem nor your explanation,
q can be any any element in Q, and the terms in set Q are not specified
q=1, q+11=1+11=12 is not multiple of 11 (we don't have to bother about it)
q=11, 11+11=22 multiple of 11 (we know 11 is there. Thus all multiples of 11 is there)
deeply confused....?
But 11 is certainly in Q and thus we can take 11 as q. Therefore for statement 1, all the positive multiples of 11 are there in Q. We are sure about it. Now there may be other integers, but we don't have to bother about it as the question is not asking whether Q is the set of all the positive multiples of 11. The question asks whether Q contains them or not.
Yes there may be other integers in Q, but you cannot assume which one is there. But we have the information that 11 is there and we have to proceed accordingly.milanproda wrote:For arguements sake, because the question said that q can denote any element in Q set, could I assume that any positive integer is in Q set? Or does the 1st stem indicate that it must be a multiple of 11?
Last edited by Anurag@Gurome on Mon Dec 27, 2010 2:08 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Anurag Mairal, Ph.D., MBA
GMAT Expert, Admissions and Career Guidance
Gurome, Inc.
18005664043 (USA)
Join Our Facebook Groups
GMAT with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/272466352793633/
Admissions with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/461459690536574/
Career Advising with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/360435787349781/
GMAT Expert, Admissions and Career Guidance
Gurome, Inc.
18005664043 (USA)
Join Our Facebook Groups
GMAT with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/272466352793633/
Admissions with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/461459690536574/
Career Advising with Gurome
https://www.facebook.com/groups/360435787349781/
 milanproda
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 58
 Joined: 25 Sep 2010
 Location: Belgrade, Serbia/ New York, USA
 Thanked: 1 times
It looks like a real Gmat question. What's the source?/ : : : : : : :milanproda wrote:Q is a set of integers and 11 is in Q. Let q (small q) denote any element in the Q set. Is every positive multiple of 11 in Q?
1 q+11 is in Q
2 q11 is in Q
Saurabh Goyal
talk_to_saurabh@yahoo.com

EveryBody Wants to Win But Nobody wants to prepare for Win.
talk_to_saurabh@yahoo.com

EveryBody Wants to Win But Nobody wants to prepare for Win.

 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 71
 Joined: 21 Feb 2010
 Thanked: 3 times
 GMAT Score:750
@Anurag: hi! Sorry but your explanation is even more confusing...
If we can have other elements apart from multiples of 11 in Q ...then we can have zero and other ve nos. as well in Q???
Please can you help here.
Thanks
If we can have other elements apart from multiples of 11 in Q ...then we can have zero and other ve nos. as well in Q???
Please can you help here.
Thanks
 nipunkathuria
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 43
 Joined: 29 Dec 2009
 Thanked: 2 times
Anurag@Gurome wrote:Yes, there may or may not be other integers in set Q.clock60 wrote:hi Anurag
honestly did not get nether problem nor your explanation,
q can be any any element in Q, and the terms in set Q are not specified
q=1, q+11=1+11=12 is not multiple of 11 (we don't have to bother about it)
q=11, 11+11=22 multiple of 11 (we know 11 is there. Thus all multiples of 11 is there)
deeply confused....?
But 11 is certainly in Q and thus we can take 11 as q. Therefore for statement 1, all the positive multiples of 11 are there in Q. We are sure about it. Now there may be other integers, but we don't have to bother about it as the question is not asking whether Q is the set of all the positive multiples of 11. The question asks whether Q contains them or not.
Yes there may be other integers in Q, but you cannot assume which one is there. But we have the information that 11 is there and we have to proceed accordingly.milanproda wrote:For arguements sake, because the question said that q can denote any element in Q set, could I assume that any positive integer is in Q set? Or does the 1st stem indicate that it must be a multiple of 11?
Hi Anurag,
I have one scenario:
If we have q=22
q+11=11,etc
so the elements can be
22.11,0,11,etc
here 22 is (2)times 11>negative multiple
If this is true , we cannot proceed with A as sufficient
But u have taken only positive number...here too we find that 11 is a member of the group
Back !!!
 Geva@EconomistGMAT
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 905
 Joined: 12 Sep 2010
 Thanked: 378 times
 Followed by:123 members
 GMAT Score:760
Just to reiterate the point made by Anurag: read the question carefully. The question asks "is every positive multiple of 11 in Q", not "does Q hold ONLY the positive multiples of 11"? As long as Q holds all positive multiples of 11, the answer to the question is "yes", even if Q holds negative multiples of 11 as well  which is why stat. (1) is sufficient.ashforgmat wrote:@Anurag: hi! Sorry but your explanation is even more confusing...
If we can have other elements apart from multiples of 11 in Q ...then we can have zero and other ve nos. as well in Q???
Please can you help here.
Thanks
Stat. (2) is insufficient because out of the positive multiples, we can only really be sure that 11 is in the set: Q will hold all negative multiples of 11, but we're not sure about the positive ones  Q MAY or MAY NOT hold the positive multiples of 11.
BTW, I would be very surprised if this were a real GMAT question. Too many abstract concepts  for one, an infinite set is highly unGMAT, IMHO.

 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 86
 Joined: 13 Sep 2010
 Thanked: 29 times
 Followed by:2 members
 GMAT Score:710
Q is a set of integers and 11 is in Q. This tells us that (a) Q is not necessarily a finite set of integers  we don't know and (b) Q contains 11
STAT #1  q+11 is in Q
we know that 11 is there in set, so 11+11 is also in set (amont other integers that we don;t care much about because Q only asks about positive multiples of 11)
However if 11+11 is there in te set then (11+11) + 11 is also there in the set (for any q, q+11 is also in set)
and same goes for further values also.
There may be other integers in set but forsure 11, 22, 33, 44, 55.... are all there
So it is SUFFICIENT
STAT #2  q11 is in Q
LEts start from what we know from stem  11 is in set.
so forsure 1111 (= 0) is in the set
and hence 011 (11) is in set and so forth.... so the set at least has 11, 0, 11, 22, 33....
it doesn;t prove anything about POSITIVE MULTIPLES of 11
Hence A
STAT #1  q+11 is in Q
we know that 11 is there in set, so 11+11 is also in set (amont other integers that we don;t care much about because Q only asks about positive multiples of 11)
However if 11+11 is there in te set then (11+11) + 11 is also there in the set (for any q, q+11 is also in set)
and same goes for further values also.
There may be other integers in set but forsure 11, 22, 33, 44, 55.... are all there
So it is SUFFICIENT
STAT #2  q11 is in Q
LEts start from what we know from stem  11 is in set.
so forsure 1111 (= 0) is in the set
and hence 011 (11) is in set and so forth.... so the set at least has 11, 0, 11, 22, 33....
it doesn;t prove anything about POSITIVE MULTIPLES of 11
Hence A
 Taran
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 57
 Joined: 01 Oct 2010
 Location: Pune, India
 Thanked: 1 times
 GMAT Score:680
Hi Guys,
What is the source of this question? Anyhow, i found the question very vaguely drafted.
1. It asks whether the Set Q contains 'every' positive multiple of 11. What if the set is {11, 22, 33, 45, 21, so on......}. In this case, we can assume q to be any integer. Considering this, we will always have positive multiples of 11. My doubt, here is that what if q is 2 and all q+11's are in the set, but only 100 multiples of 11 are there. I hope my question is clear to all.
What is the source of this question? Anyhow, i found the question very vaguely drafted.
1. It asks whether the Set Q contains 'every' positive multiple of 11. What if the set is {11, 22, 33, 45, 21, so on......}. In this case, we can assume q to be any integer. Considering this, we will always have positive multiples of 11. My doubt, here is that what if q is 2 and all q+11's are in the set, but only 100 multiples of 11 are there. I hope my question is clear to all.
Yes I agree with Anurag:
when you set 11 as a q, then q+11 is in the set ===>( q+11)+11 is in as well and as a transitive property this is infinite.
11, 11+q, 11+2q,...... 11+nq when n is any positive integer, hence all of these elements are positive and are multiples of 11.
With 2),
1111, leads to 0 and when you continue this. Numbers you get are negative and this only shows 0, 11, and negative multiples of 11.
Be careful and not select D!!
The answer is A only!
I hope I helped.
when you set 11 as a q, then q+11 is in the set ===>( q+11)+11 is in as well and as a transitive property this is infinite.
11, 11+q, 11+2q,...... 11+nq when n is any positive integer, hence all of these elements are positive and are multiples of 11.
With 2),
1111, leads to 0 and when you continue this. Numbers you get are negative and this only shows 0, 11, and negative multiples of 11.
Be careful and not select D!!
The answer is A only!
I hope I helped.