An a small raffle, there are only 2 prizes, and 30 tickets sold. A boy has 3 tickets in the raggle. Find the probability that he wins:
a) the first prize
b) both prizes
c) only the 2nd prie
d) a prize
Please detail your explanation/solution, I need to solve this kind of problem
thanks
Andrew
raffle: probability
This topic has expert replies
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Wed Mar 04, 2009 4:39 am
- Location: Vancouver
- Thanked: 9 times
- GMAT Score:750
a) There's only 1 first prize in 30 tickets. If the boy has 1 ticket, his probability is 1/30. When he has 3 tickets, it's 3*1/30=1/10.
b) To win first prize, his probability is 1/10; to win 2nd prize, probability is 2/29 (29 tickets left). To win both, probability is 1/10*2/29=1/145
c) The probability to win the 2nd prize is the same as that of the 1st prize, 1/10
d) Since there're 2 prizes available in 30 tickets, probability to win a prize with 1 ticket is 2/30=1/15. With 3 tickets, his probability to win is 3*1/15=1/5
b) To win first prize, his probability is 1/10; to win 2nd prize, probability is 2/29 (29 tickets left). To win both, probability is 1/10*2/29=1/145
c) The probability to win the 2nd prize is the same as that of the 1st prize, 1/10
d) Since there're 2 prizes available in 30 tickets, probability to win a prize with 1 ticket is 2/30=1/15. With 3 tickets, his probability to win is 3*1/15=1/5
GMAT/MBA Expert
- Ian Stewart
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 2621
- Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 3:17 am
- Location: Montreal
- Thanked: 1090 times
- Followed by:355 members
- GMAT Score:780
I agree with your solutions to a) and b).pakaskwa wrote:
c) The probability to win the 2nd prize is the same as that of the 1st prize, 1/10
For c), I interpret the question differently; when it says "*only* the second prize", I take that to mean "the second prize but *not* the first prize". If we take that interpretation, the other two tickets need to be losing tickets, and the probability should be (1/10)*(28/29)*(27/28) = 27/290.
Alternatively, for c), you could use the results from a) and b). The probability that he wins the second prize is 1/10 (the same as the probability he wins the first prize). Then,
Prob(he wins *only* the 2nd prize) = Prob(he wins 2nd prize) - Prob(he wins both prizes) = (Answer from question a) - (Answer from question b)
= 1/10 - 1/145 = 27/290.
For d), you can apply a simple logical test to see that the method is not quite right. By the method above, if he bought 15 tickets, he would be absolutely certain to win a prize, and if he bought 18 tickets, he'd have a 120% chance of winning a prize. Since he won't be certain to win a prize unless he buys 29 tickets, the method above cannot be correct. We could answer the question as follows:pakaskwa wrote: d) Since there're 2 prizes available in 30 tickets, probability to win a prize with 1 ticket is 2/30=1/15. With 3 tickets, his probability to win is 3*1/15=1/5
Prob(he wins at least one prize) = 1 - Prob(he wins no prizes) = 1 - Prob(all three tickets lose)
= 1 - (28/30)(27/29)(26/28)
= 1 - (9/10)(26/29)
= 28/145
Alternatively, we could use the results from b) and c) above. From c), his probability of *only* winning the first prize is 27/290; his probability of *only* winning the second prize is 27/290; and his probability of winning both prizes, from b), is 2/290. So his probability of winning a prize = Prob(wins only 1st prize) + Prob(wins only 2nd prize) + Prob(wins both prizes) = 27/290 + 27/290 + 2/290 = 56/290 = 28/145. I actually did that with a Venn diagram, but it's hard to reproduce here.
For online GMAT math tutoring, or to buy my higher-level Quant books and problem sets, contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com
ianstewartgmat.com
ianstewartgmat.com
-
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 12:50 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Thanked: 3 times
No schocker here but I think Ian is correct.
For probablity always try to get the statment to say "and" so you can multiply the probabilities so C would read:
Prob(of not winning prize 1) & Prob(of winning prize 2)
Prob(of not winning prize 1)=1-Prob(of winning prize 1)=1-(3/30)=27/30
(27/30)*(3/29)=27/290
And D would best be read as: 1-Prob(not winning 1)*Prob(not winning 2)
Prob(not winning 2)=26/29=Number of tickets not his/total tickets left
1-(27/30)(26/29)=1-(117/145)
For probablity always try to get the statment to say "and" so you can multiply the probabilities so C would read:
Prob(of not winning prize 1) & Prob(of winning prize 2)
Prob(of not winning prize 1)=1-Prob(of winning prize 1)=1-(3/30)=27/30
(27/30)*(3/29)=27/290
And D would best be read as: 1-Prob(not winning 1)*Prob(not winning 2)
Prob(not winning 2)=26/29=Number of tickets not his/total tickets left
1-(27/30)(26/29)=1-(117/145)