Data Sufficiency

AbeNeedsAnswers wrote:If q, s and t are all different numbers, is q < s < t?

(1) t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|
(2) t > q

We need to determine whether q < s < t, given that q, s, and t are all different numbers.

Statement One Alone:

t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|

Since q, s, and t are different numbers, both |t - s| and |s - q| are positive quantities, and their sum |t - s| + |s - q| will also be positive. This also makes the left-hand side t - q positive. Since t - q > 0, we have t > q.

We know t > q, but we still have to determine whether s is between them. That is, is q < s < t? We have three scenarios to consider.

(1) If q < s < t, then t > s and s > q, and then:

t - q = t - s + s - q

t - q = t - q

We see that this equation holds true: t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|, and furthermore q < s < t.

(2) If s < q < t, then t > s and q > s, and thus t -s is positive while s - q is negative, and we have:

|t - s| + |s - q|

t - s + [-(s - q)]

t - s - s + q

t - 2s + q ≠ t - q

Since t - 2s + q ≠ t - q, the equation does not hold and we can't have s < q < t.

(3) If q < t < s, then s > t and s > q, and thus t - s is negative while s - q is positive, and we have:

|t - s| + |s - q|

-(t - s) + s - q

-t + s + s - q

-t + 2s - q

Since -t + 2s - q ≠ t - q, we see that the equation does not hold, so we can't have q < t < s.

We see that only scenario 1 is true if t - q = |t - s| + |s - q,| and we do have q < s < t. Statement one alone is sufficient.

Statement Two Alone:

t > q

We know t > q, but we still have to determine whether s is between them. It's possible that q < s < t, but it is also possible that s < q < t or q < t < s. Since we don't know anything about s, we can't determine which case is valid. Statement two alone is not sufficient.

Answer: A

AbeNeedsAnswers wrote:If q, s and t are all different numbers, is q < s < t?

(1) t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|
(2) t > q

A

Given: q, s, and t are all different numbers

Target question: Is q < s < t ?

Statement 1: t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|
Since q, s, and t are all different numbers, we know that |t - s| is POSITIVE, and |s - q| is POSITIVE.
So, t - q = some positive number
From this we can conclude that: q < t
On the number line we have something like this:

From here we need only determine whether s is between q and t

To help us we can use a nice property that says: |x - y| = the distance between x and y on the number line
For example: |3 - 10| = 7, so the distance between 3 and 10 on the number line is 7

So, the statement "t - q = |t - s| + |s - q|" tells us that: (the distance between t and q) = (the distance between t and s) + (the distance between s and q)
The ONLY time this equation holds true is when is between q and t

Given this, it MUST be the case that q < s < t

Since we can answer the target question with certainty, statement 1 is SUFFICIENT

Statement 2: t > q
Since there is no information about s, we cannot answer the target question with certainty.
Statement 2 is NOT SUFFICIENT

Answer: A

Cheers,
Brent