Source: Beat The GMAT Practice Questions
If there are more oak trees in Oregon than there are leaves on any one Oregon oak tree, and if every Oregon oak tree has at least one leaf, then __________.
Which of the following most logically completes the passage?
A. the average number of oak leaves per Oregon oak tree must be less than half the number of Oregon oak trees
B. there are fewer leaves on at least one Oregon oak tree than half the number of those trees
C. there must be at least two oak trees in Oregon with the same number of leaves
D. there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves, as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves
E. there must be more oak trees than any other type of tree in Oregon
Oak trees

 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 250
 Joined: 07 Jan 2010
 Thanked: 10 times
Wow!!!!
what options...i wish not to see such CR's on D day...
IMO:A
what options...i wish not to see such CR's on D day...
IMO:A
Thanks and regards,
Saurabh Mahajan
I can understand you not winning,but i will not forgive you for not trying.
Saurabh Mahajan
I can understand you not winning,but i will not forgive you for not trying.
 abhi84v
 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 39
 Joined: 10 Jun 2010
 Location: Sydney, Australia
 Thanked: 7 times
 GMAT Score:770
IMO C
Let's say any tree has x leaves max
n > x
so say all trees have different no of leaves and each has at least one leaf
So the no of leaves on the trees can be 1,2,....,x
However there are more than x trees
So it stands to reason that there are at least two trees with the same number of leaves
Let's say any tree has x leaves max
n > x
so say all trees have different no of leaves and each has at least one leaf
So the no of leaves on the trees can be 1,2,....,x
However there are more than x trees
So it stands to reason that there are at least two trees with the same number of leaves
 DanaJ
 Site Admin
 Posts: 2567
 Joined: 01 Jan 2009
 Thanked: 712 times
 Followed by:550 members
 GMAT Score:770
This one made my brain hurt as well...
Here's the explanation from the Beat The GMAT Practice Questions, hope you enjoy it as much as I did!
Try to make the problem more solvable by simplifying. First, delete the words "oak" and "Oregon." This helps remove unnecessary clutter. Second, try to solve by working with a finite number of trees and leaves:
If we have four trees, then each tree has at least one leaf but no more than three.
(C) is true for any number of trees. For example, if there are three trees, one tree may have one leaf, another tree may have two leaves, but if the third tree had either three or no leaves, then that would contradict the initial statement. The third tree must have either one or two leaves (i.e., at least two trees must have the same number of leaves).
(A) is not necessarily true; if, for instance, we have four trees, each of them could have three leaves.
(B) is impossible if there are only two trees because each tree must have at least one leaf (as weird as it may sound to have just two trees in Oregon!)
(D) isn't necessarily true; for example, all trees could have the same number of leaves. This is a typical example of confusing syntax.
(E) is out because there's no talk about any other tree type. We're strictly interested in oak trees!
Here's the explanation from the Beat The GMAT Practice Questions, hope you enjoy it as much as I did!
Try to make the problem more solvable by simplifying. First, delete the words "oak" and "Oregon." This helps remove unnecessary clutter. Second, try to solve by working with a finite number of trees and leaves:
If we have four trees, then each tree has at least one leaf but no more than three.
(C) is true for any number of trees. For example, if there are three trees, one tree may have one leaf, another tree may have two leaves, but if the third tree had either three or no leaves, then that would contradict the initial statement. The third tree must have either one or two leaves (i.e., at least two trees must have the same number of leaves).
(A) is not necessarily true; if, for instance, we have four trees, each of them could have three leaves.
(B) is impossible if there are only two trees because each tree must have at least one leaf (as weird as it may sound to have just two trees in Oregon!)
(D) isn't necessarily true; for example, all trees could have the same number of leaves. This is a typical example of confusing syntax.
(E) is out because there's no talk about any other tree type. We're strictly interested in oak trees!

 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 126
 Joined: 19 Jul 2010
 Thanked: 6 times
Took me nearly 2 mins to select C.... This is a 700+ q for sure...DanaJ wrote:Source: Beat The GMAT Practice Questions
If there are more oak trees in Oregon than there are leaves on any one Oregon oak tree, and if every Oregon oak tree has at least one leaf, then __________.
Which of the following most logically completes the passage?
A. the average number of oak leaves per Oregon oak tree must be less than half the number of Oregon oak trees
B. there are fewer leaves on at least one Oregon oak tree than half the number of those trees
C. there must be at least two oak trees in Oregon with the same number of leaves
D. there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves, as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves
E. there must be more oak trees than any other type of tree in Oregon
 Abhishek009
 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 359
 Joined: 11 Mar 2009
 Location: INDIA
 Thanked: 50 times
 Followed by:2 members
Will go with C....DanaJ wrote:Source: Beat The GMAT Practice Questions
If there are more oak trees in Oregon than there are leaves on any one Oregon oak tree, and if every Oregon oak tree has at least one leaf, then __________.
Which of the following most logically completes the passage?
A. the average number of oak leaves per Oregon oak tree must be less than half the number of Oregon oak trees
B. there are fewer leaves on at least one Oregon oak tree than half the number of those trees
C. there must be at least two oak trees in Oregon with the same number of leaves
D. there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves, as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves
E. there must be more oak trees than any other type of tree in Oregon
Abhishek

 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 58
 Joined: 22 Oct 2010
 Location: Bhopal
 Thanked: 1 times
 GMAT Score:710
My answer "C"  t = no of trees and n = no of leaves atleast per tree... since t>n if n =1 then there must be two trees and both of them must have 1 leave each. If t =3 then the max no of leaves per tree =2 again if the first two trees have 1 and 2 leaves.. the third tree must have either 1 or 2 leaves........and so on by induction we can prove CDanaJ wrote:Source: Beat The GMAT Practice Questions
If there are more oak trees in Oregon than there are leaves on any one Oregon oak tree, and if every Oregon oak tree has at least one leaf, then __________.
Which of the following most logically completes the passage?
A. the average number of oak leaves per Oregon oak tree must be less than half the number of Oregon oak trees
B. there are fewer leaves on at least one Oregon oak tree than half the number of those trees
C. there must be at least two oak trees in Oregon with the same number of leaves
D. there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves, as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves
E. there must be more oak trees than any other type of tree in Oregon
 rishab1988
 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 332
 Joined: 09 Feb 2010
 Thanked: 41 times
 Followed by:7 members
 GMAT Score:720
The answer should be C.
But I must add D is a very poorly constructed sentence.
"there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves"
"as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves. "
D basically meant to say,if the there are 4 oak trees and 3 of those trees have 2 leaves and one of those trees has 1 leaf, then the number of oak trees[most number of leaves here is 2] that have 1 leaf must be same the number of oak trees that have 2 leaves.
As indicates comparison.what is the second part comparing to?
But I must add D is a very poorly constructed sentence.
"there must be at least as many Oregon oak trees with half as many leaves as the Oregon tree with the most leaves"
"as there are Oregon oak trees with twice as many leaves as the Oregon oak tree with the fewest leaves. "
D basically meant to say,if the there are 4 oak trees and 3 of those trees have 2 leaves and one of those trees has 1 leaf, then the number of oak trees[most number of leaves here is 2] that have 1 leaf must be same the number of oak trees that have 2 leaves.
As indicates comparison.what is the second part comparing to?
 anirudhbhalotia
 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 123
 Joined: 23 Nov 2010
 Location: Mumbai, India
 Thanked: 5 times
 Followed by:4 members
 rishab1988
 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 332
 Joined: 09 Feb 2010
 Thanked: 41 times
 Followed by:7 members
 GMAT Score:720
Don't worry about this one.
There are 2 issues about it
1) This is a very very LSAT like CR [you will never encounter such CR on GMAT]
Even if you did.You still need not worry for the following reason:
2) The language in statement D is ambiguous.The real test questions are very carefully edited.
I have done almost 200 LSAT CR questions,till date,and I have never encounter such ambiguous language as in answer choice D.Yes I have seen an LSAT question similar to this one but not with an ambiguous language as this one.
There are 2 issues about it
1) This is a very very LSAT like CR [you will never encounter such CR on GMAT]
Even if you did.You still need not worry for the following reason:
2) The language in statement D is ambiguous.The real test questions are very carefully edited.
I have done almost 200 LSAT CR questions,till date,and I have never encounter such ambiguous language as in answer choice D.Yes I have seen an LSAT question similar to this one but not with an ambiguous language as this one.
 arora007
 Community Manager
 Posts: 1049
 Joined: 17 Aug 2009
 Location: India
 Thanked: 51 times
 Followed by:27 members
 GMAT Score:670
Oh boy what was that!! Dana really u made it very simple...
https://www.skiponemeal.org/
https://twitter.com/skiponemeal
Few things are impossible to diligence & skill.Great works are performed not by strength,but by perseverance
pm me if you find junk/spam/abusive language, Lets keep our community clean!!
https://twitter.com/skiponemeal
Few things are impossible to diligence & skill.Great works are performed not by strength,but by perseverance
pm me if you find junk/spam/abusive language, Lets keep our community clean!!