In a library, N books are placed on seven shelves averagely, and one is remained on the desk. what is N ?
1). If they are place on nine shelves averagely, seven books will be remained.
2). If they are place on four shelves averagely, three books will be remained.
I got a number i.e. 43 that satisfies both the statements but please tell me is there any other number that satisfies the above statements and how to get all those numbers in 2mins.. coz the final answer depends on the numbers if there are any except 43.. Please lemme know the easier method to do it..
library
This topic has expert replies

 Legendary Member
 Posts: 752
 Joined: 17 May 2009
 Location: Tokyo
 Thanked: 81 times
 GMAT Score:680
IMO E
N books are placed on seven shelves averagely, and one is remained on the desk
so numbers can be 8,15,22,29 and so on
If they are place on nine shelves averagely, seven books will be remained
numbers can be 16,25...and so on
If they are place on four shelves averagely, three books will be remained.
numbers are 7,11..and so on
combining all
8+7n1=16+9n2=7+4n3
can't find the values of n1,n2 and n3
N books are placed on seven shelves averagely, and one is remained on the desk
so numbers can be 8,15,22,29 and so on
If they are place on nine shelves averagely, seven books will be remained
numbers can be 16,25...and so on
If they are place on four shelves averagely, three books will be remained.
numbers are 7,11..and so on
combining all
8+7n1=16+9n2=7+4n3
can't find the values of n1,n2 and n3
The powers of two are bloody impolite!!

 Master  Next Rank: 500 Posts
 Posts: 431
 Joined: 10 Jan 2009
 Thanked: 16 times
 Followed by:1 members
hmm..I actually don't understand your logic. Can you please elaborate?tohellandback wrote:IMO E
N books are placed on seven shelves averagely, and one is remained on the desk
so numbers can be 8,15,22,29 and so on
If they are place on nine shelves averagely, seven books will be remained
numbers can be 16,25...and so on
If they are place on four shelves averagely, three books will be remained.
numbers are 7,11..and so on
combining all
8+7n1=16+9n2=7+4n3
can't find the values of n1,n2 and n3
Thanks,
kanha81
Want to Beat GMAT.
Always do what you're afraid to do. Whoooop GMAT
Always do what you're afraid to do. Whoooop GMAT
GMAT/MBA Expert
 [email protected]
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 3225
 Joined: 08 Jan 2008
 Location: Toronto
 Thanked: 1710 times
 Followed by:613 members
 GMAT Score:800
First, let me say that this is a horribly worded question  where's it from? "Averagely" isn't even a word and the grammar is horrible.ketkoag wrote:In a library, N books are placed on seven shelves averagely, and one is remained on the desk. what is N ?
1). If they are place on nine shelves averagely, seven books will be remained.
2). If they are place on four shelves averagely, three books will be remained.
So, either you should never trust questions from this source or you should do a better job transcribing the questions that you post.
However, we can use our decoder ring to figure out how the question should have read:
Step 1 of the Kaplan method for DS: focus on the question stem.N books are equally distributed among 7 shelves in a library. If 1 book remains on the desk, what's the value of N?
We want to know exacly how many books we started with. We're told that N/7 has a remainder of 1. So, we know that N=1, 8, 15, 22, ...
Step 2 of the Kaplan method for DS: consider each statement alone, in conjuction with the stem.
(1) N/9 has a remainder of 7. So, N=7, 16, 25, ...
Is this sufficient to determine the value of N? No  since we have no maximum value, there will be an infinite number of points of intersection between the two sets we have for N.
For example, N could be 43. However, N could also be 106, 169, ... (since 7*9=63, you can just add 63 to each number to find the next possible solution).
We can get more than one value for N: insufficient.
(2) N/4 has a remainder of 3.
Using the exact same logic as above, there will be an inifinite number of possible values for N: insufficient.
Step 3 of the Kaplan method for DS: if necessary, combine the statements.
Now we have 3 facts about N:
N/7 has remainder 1, N/9 has remainder 7, N/4 has remainder 3.
However, using the exact same logic as we did in (1) above, there will be an infinite number of possible values for N that satisfy these conditions: insufficient, choose (E).
Stuart Kovinsky  Kaplan GMAT Faculty  Toronto
Kaplan Exclusive: The Official Test Day Experience  Ready to Take a Free Practice Test?  Kaplan/Beat the GMAT Member Discount
BTG100 for $100 off a full course
GMAT/MBA Expert
 [email protected]
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 3225
 Joined: 08 Jan 2008
 Location: Toronto
 Thanked: 1710 times
 Followed by:613 members
 GMAT Score:800
Here's what you should have been thinking: I got a number that works. Out of all the numbers in the universe, is there reason for me to believe that no other numbers will also work?ketkoag wrote:I got a number i.e. 43 that satisfies both the statements but please tell me is there any other number that satisfies the above statements and how to get all those numbers in 2mins.. coz the final answer depends on the numbers if there are any except 43.. Please lemme know the easier method to do it.
Knowing that factors/multiples/remainders recur in infinite patterns, the answer to that question should have been "no, there isn't  lots of numbers will work". Once you figure that out, there's no need to actually go looking for another number  just knowing that many exist is enough reason to choose (E).
Remember  our goal in DS is to do as little work as possible. On value questions, we don't need to actually calculate the value(s), we just need to recognize if there's exactly one value or multiple values.
Stuart Kovinsky  Kaplan GMAT Faculty  Toronto
Kaplan Exclusive: The Official Test Day Experience  Ready to Take a Free Practice Test?  Kaplan/Beat the GMAT Member Discount
BTG100 for $100 off a full course
thanks for the great explanation..
sure, i'll not use this source in future.
i got this question from the internet and posted it as it is..
i'll definitely transcribe any weird structure before posting it in future.
thanks again..
sure, i'll not use this source in future.
i got this question from the internet and posted it as it is..
i'll definitely transcribe any weird structure before posting it in future.
thanks again..