Galileo did not invent the telescope, but on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he quickly built his own device from an organ pipe and spectacle lenses.
A. Galileo did not invent the telescope, but on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
B. Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard, in 1609, of such an optical instrument having been made,
C. Galileo, even though he had not invented the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
E. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, but when he heard, 1609, of such an optical instrument being made, he
OA - A.
Galileo -GPREP SC.
This topic has expert replies
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 759
- Joined: Mon Apr 26, 2010 10:15 am
- Thanked: 85 times
- Followed by:3 members
it is easier to show why other answers are incorrect, than to prove that A is correct
my approaach
B and D, they lack subject he in the second half of the sentence
b)Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard,he quickly built his own the same problem in Din B and D he is missed
E) Even though......,but -together seems redundant, also being not best construction.
C) don`t know what is exact problem , even though he had not invented the telescope, not essential modifier in the problem, that can be put off. but we need this information. also i don`t like past perfect used twice he had not invented the telescope, had been made, it is not clear what action was first
my approaach
B and D, they lack subject he in the second half of the sentence
b)Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard,he quickly built his own the same problem in Din B and D he is missed
E) Even though......,but -together seems redundant, also being not best construction.
C) don`t know what is exact problem , even though he had not invented the telescope, not essential modifier in the problem, that can be put off. but we need this information. also i don`t like past perfect used twice he had not invented the telescope, had been made, it is not clear what action was first
GMAT/MBA Expert
- e-GMAT
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 645
- Joined: Mon Jul 26, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: US
- Thanked: 527 times
- Followed by:227 members
Galileo did not invent the telescope, but on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he quickly built his own device from an organ pipe and spectacle lenses.
A. Galileo did not invent the telescope, but on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
B. Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard, in 1609, of such an optical instrument having been made,
C. Galileo, even though he had not invented the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
E. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, but when he heard, 1609, of such an optical instrument being made, he
Step 1: Understand the meaning of the sentence
This sentence presents a contrast
1: Galileo did not invent the telescope
2: But when he heard that someone had made such an optical instrument, he quickly built his version of telescope
Step 2: Perform Error Analysis on the original sentence
1: Galileo did not invent the telescope,
2: but
3: on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
2: he quickly built his own device from an organ pipe and spectacle lenses.
There are 3 clauses in this sentence as shown. Clause 2 is separated from clause 1 using ", but". All SV pairs are accounted for.
Next we will check for verb tenses.
This sentence is established in past time frame.
Clause 1 event = did not invent
Clause 2 event = had been made
Clause 3 event = built
Per the intended meaning, the events in clauses 2 and 3 are related. Clause 3 event takes place after the clause 2 event. This sequencing is shown well with the use of past perfect tense for the clause 2 event (prior event). Thus, there are no verb errors as well.
There are no other apparent grammatical errors in this sentence. The use of expression "on hearing" may sound awkward but it is not an error. If we can eliminate the remaining 4 choices based on concrete grammatical or meaning grounds, then Choice A is the correct answer.
Step 3: Perform POE
B. Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard, in 1609, of such an optical instrument having been made,
Errors:
1: "had not invented" is used in isolation with no other related event in simple past tense.
2: "having been made" is unnecessarily passive.
3: No subject for verb - built.
C. Galileo, even though he had not invented the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
Errors:
1: No verb for subject - Galileo
2: "had not invented" is used in isolation with no other related event in simple past tense.
3: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author
D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
Errors:
1: No subject for verb - built.
2: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author
E. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, but when he heard, 1609, of such an optical instrument being made, he
Errors:
1: Redundant use - even though - but
2: Incorrect verb tense - being made - appears as a continuous action in the past. Does not communicate the intended meaning that the optical instrument was made.
3: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author.
I hope the above explanation helps.
Regards,
Payal
A. Galileo did not invent the telescope, but on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
B. Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard, in 1609, of such an optical instrument having been made,
C. Galileo, even though he had not invented the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
E. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, but when he heard, 1609, of such an optical instrument being made, he
Step 1: Understand the meaning of the sentence
This sentence presents a contrast
1: Galileo did not invent the telescope
2: But when he heard that someone had made such an optical instrument, he quickly built his version of telescope
Step 2: Perform Error Analysis on the original sentence
1: Galileo did not invent the telescope,
2: but
3: on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
2: he quickly built his own device from an organ pipe and spectacle lenses.
There are 3 clauses in this sentence as shown. Clause 2 is separated from clause 1 using ", but". All SV pairs are accounted for.
Next we will check for verb tenses.
This sentence is established in past time frame.
Clause 1 event = did not invent
Clause 2 event = had been made
Clause 3 event = built
Per the intended meaning, the events in clauses 2 and 3 are related. Clause 3 event takes place after the clause 2 event. This sequencing is shown well with the use of past perfect tense for the clause 2 event (prior event). Thus, there are no verb errors as well.
There are no other apparent grammatical errors in this sentence. The use of expression "on hearing" may sound awkward but it is not an error. If we can eliminate the remaining 4 choices based on concrete grammatical or meaning grounds, then Choice A is the correct answer.
Step 3: Perform POE
B. Galileo had not invented the telescope, but when he heard, in 1609, of such an optical instrument having been made,
Errors:
1: "had not invented" is used in isolation with no other related event in simple past tense.
2: "having been made" is unnecessarily passive.
3: No subject for verb - built.
C. Galileo, even though he had not invented the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made, he
Errors:
1: No verb for subject - Galileo
2: "had not invented" is used in isolation with no other related event in simple past tense.
3: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author
D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
Errors:
1: No subject for verb - built.
2: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author
E. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, but when he heard, 1609, of such an optical instrument being made, he
Errors:
1: Redundant use - even though - but
2: Incorrect verb tense - being made - appears as a continuous action in the past. Does not communicate the intended meaning that the optical instrument was made.
3: Use of "even though" changes the intended meaning. It no longer establishes a mere contrast. It now expresses a paradox which is not the intention of the author.
I hope the above explanation helps.
Regards,
Payal
Last edited by e-GMAT on Tue Nov 02, 2010 7:29 am, edited 2 times in total.
Register for free live sessions
Sentence Correction: Get 4 free video lessons, 50 practice questions
Critical Reasoning workshop: Get 4 free video lessons, 40 practice questions
Reading Comprehension: Get 2 free video lessons and 2 free eBooks
Free Strategy Session: Key strategy to score 760
Success Stories
V27 to V42 | V28 to V48 | V25 to V38 | More Success Stories
Sentence Correction: Get 4 free video lessons, 50 practice questions
Critical Reasoning workshop: Get 4 free video lessons, 40 practice questions
Reading Comprehension: Get 2 free video lessons and 2 free eBooks
Free Strategy Session: Key strategy to score 760
Success Stories
V27 to V42 | V28 to V48 | V25 to V38 | More Success Stories
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2009 3:46 am
- Thanked: 21 times
- Followed by:7 members
@ Payal: thanks for great explanation. i have got question :
For me, the error in D is misplaced contrast sub-ordinator (even though) . But need your confirmation whether my understanding is correct.
This error is there in all sentences including the correct answer choice A . How could we eliminate D based on this ?D. Even though Galileo did not invent the telescope, on hearing, in 1609, that such an optical instrument had been made,
Errors: 1: No subject for verb - made.
For me, the error in D is misplaced contrast sub-ordinator (even though) . But need your confirmation whether my understanding is correct.
GMAT/MBA Expert
- e-GMAT
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 645
- Joined: Mon Jul 26, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: US
- Thanked: 527 times
- Followed by:227 members
Hi gmatmadeasy,
I realized that there was a typo in my post - For choices B and D, I meant to say "no subject for verb - built" but by mistake I said "no subject for verb - made". I have edited that in my post.
Please review Choice D with the edit and let me know if you have any concerns with that.
As far as placement of "even though" in Choice D goes, your reasoning is correct. Choices C, D, and E change the meaning of the sentence since they use "even though". Even though is used when we need to express a contradictory information or a paradox. In this case we need to show a contrast (this is done well using 'but').
For the sake of completeness, I will edit my post to include the meaning error as well in Choices C, D, and E.
I realized that there was a typo in my post - For choices B and D, I meant to say "no subject for verb - built" but by mistake I said "no subject for verb - made". I have edited that in my post.
Please review Choice D with the edit and let me know if you have any concerns with that.
As far as placement of "even though" in Choice D goes, your reasoning is correct. Choices C, D, and E change the meaning of the sentence since they use "even though". Even though is used when we need to express a contradictory information or a paradox. In this case we need to show a contrast (this is done well using 'but').
For the sake of completeness, I will edit my post to include the meaning error as well in Choices C, D, and E.
Register for free live sessions
Sentence Correction: Get 4 free video lessons, 50 practice questions
Critical Reasoning workshop: Get 4 free video lessons, 40 practice questions
Reading Comprehension: Get 2 free video lessons and 2 free eBooks
Free Strategy Session: Key strategy to score 760
Success Stories
V27 to V42 | V28 to V48 | V25 to V38 | More Success Stories
Sentence Correction: Get 4 free video lessons, 50 practice questions
Critical Reasoning workshop: Get 4 free video lessons, 40 practice questions
Reading Comprehension: Get 2 free video lessons and 2 free eBooks
Free Strategy Session: Key strategy to score 760
Success Stories
V27 to V42 | V28 to V48 | V25 to V38 | More Success Stories