Data Sufficiency

If R =Q/P , is R = P ?
(1) P > 50
(2) 0 < Q < 20

OA - is C...

Have u correctly posted ur Qs? I am having some doubt. IMO E. It should not be C.

If R =Q/P , is R = P ?

(1) P > 50

noe for R =P q =P^2 here q may be = p^2 or not INSUFF

(2) 0 < Q <20>50 & 0 < Q < 20

so here q <> p^2 & since q is less than P so R will be a decimal between 0 & 1 which will always be < 50

so R <> P

SUFF

C

Well this is what I think..

Stat 1- P is greater than 50 so values can be 51,52 or even 1000.Moreover nothing about Q is given so INSUFFICIENT.

Stat 2 - Q has values from 1 to 19.Again nothing about P is given so INSUFFICIENT.

Combining the statements we know that Q's values are from 1 to 19 inclusive and P is always greater than 51.

Lets select two values for P and Q

P=51
Q=19

then, R=Q/P would give R=19/51=0.37 so R is not equal to P

Since 19 is the maximum value for Q the numerator will always be smaller than the denominator and hence R can never be equal to P. So answer is C.

But I have a weird feeling about this question.Is it right??

Hey Samir is my approach right??

perfect