In the figure shown, the circle has center O and radius 50, and point P has coordinates (50,0). If point Q (not shown) is on the circle, what is the length of line segment PQ ?
1) The x-coordinate of point Q is – 30.
2) The y-coordinate of point Q is – 40.
OA is A
I fell for C can someone explain???
Thanks much in anticipation!
Cunning Circle!
This topic has expert replies
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 8:13 am
- Location: New Jersey
- GMAT Score:650
in
a) point can be (-30, +x) or (-30, -x) -- we can figure out x by sqrt(50^2-30^2), but we don't care of the actual number... we care about the length from each point to (0, 50)... the length is same from each point
--> sufficient
b) point (+y, -40) or (-y, -40) -- again we can figure out y, but length will be different for each point (+ and -) so unless we know which point it is (+ or -) we cannot find out length -- insufficient
so ans is A
-- btw if you graph this on scrap paper it's much easier to see
a) point can be (-30, +x) or (-30, -x) -- we can figure out x by sqrt(50^2-30^2), but we don't care of the actual number... we care about the length from each point to (0, 50)... the length is same from each point
--> sufficient
b) point (+y, -40) or (-y, -40) -- again we can figure out y, but length will be different for each point (+ and -) so unless we know which point it is (+ or -) we cannot find out length -- insufficient
so ans is A
-- btw if you graph this on scrap paper it's much easier to see
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 8:13 am
- Location: New Jersey
- GMAT Score:650
I dont get your explanation for A.. Can you provide details as to how x is figured by sqrt (50^2-30^2)??m&m wrote:in
a) point can be (-30, +x) or (-30, -x) -- we can figure out x by sqrt(50^2-30^2), but we don't care of the actual number... we care about the length from each point to (0, 50)... the length is same from each point
--> sufficient
b) point (+y, -40) or (-y, -40) -- again we can figure out y, but length will be different for each point (+ and -) so unless we know which point it is (+ or -) we cannot find out length -- insufficient
so ans is A
-- btw if you graph this on scrap paper it's much easier to see
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Sat Apr 18, 2009 10:41 pm
- Thanked: 9 times
- GMAT Score:770
Point (50,0) is on the circle. We don't know that centre of the circle. The centre can be (0,0) or (100,0)
Looking at the statements 1 and 2 , we see negative values. Hence we can consider the centre at (0,0)
Statement 1
sqrt((-30)^2 + (y)^2) = 50
solving this y = -40 or y=40
So, the points can be (-30, -40) or (-30, 40)
When (-30,-40) or (-30,40) distance PQ = sqrt(80^2 + 40^2)
Hence sufficient
From Statement 2
sqrt(x^2 + (-40)^2) = 50
x= 30 or x= -30
Points are (30,-40) or (-30,-40)
When point =(30,-40) dist PQ = sqrt( 20^2 + 40^2)
When point =(-30, -40) dist PQ = sqrt( 80^2 + 40^2)
Hence not sufficient
Ans A
The same problem would have ans as B if in the main statement the x-coordinate of point P is 0 and y-coordinate is non-zero.
Cool problem..
Looking at the statements 1 and 2 , we see negative values. Hence we can consider the centre at (0,0)
Statement 1
sqrt((-30)^2 + (y)^2) = 50
solving this y = -40 or y=40
So, the points can be (-30, -40) or (-30, 40)
When (-30,-40) or (-30,40) distance PQ = sqrt(80^2 + 40^2)
Hence sufficient
From Statement 2
sqrt(x^2 + (-40)^2) = 50
x= 30 or x= -30
Points are (30,-40) or (-30,-40)
When point =(30,-40) dist PQ = sqrt( 20^2 + 40^2)
When point =(-30, -40) dist PQ = sqrt( 80^2 + 40^2)
Hence not sufficient
Ans A
The same problem would have ans as B if in the main statement the x-coordinate of point P is 0 and y-coordinate is non-zero.
Cool problem..
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 131
- Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 1:01 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Thanked: 7 times
Agree with A.
Good Problem.
I am assuming the center to be at (0,0)
1) the two possible points are (-30,y) & (-30,-y) you can see the distance between (50,0) and these is same sqrt(80^2 + y^2)
2) possible points are (x,-40) & (-x,-40)
d1 = sqrt( (50-x)^2 + 40^2 )
d1 = sqrt( (50+x)^2 + 40^2)
Vinayak
Good Problem.
I am assuming the center to be at (0,0)
1) the two possible points are (-30,y) & (-30,-y) you can see the distance between (50,0) and these is same sqrt(80^2 + y^2)
2) possible points are (x,-40) & (-x,-40)
d1 = sqrt( (50-x)^2 + 40^2 )
d1 = sqrt( (50+x)^2 + 40^2)
Vinayak
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 197
- Joined: Sun May 18, 2008 2:47 am
- Thanked: 12 times
p is a point that is on the x-axis, which splits the circle in half. so as long as point q is on the other side of the y-axis the length formed is measurable.KICKGMATASS123 wrote:In the figure shown, the circle has center O and radius 50, and point P has coordinates (50,0). If point Q (not shown) is on the circle, what is the length of line segment PQ ?
1) The x-coordinate of point Q is – 30.
2) The y-coordinate of point Q is – 40.
OA is A
I fell for C can someone explain???
Thanks much in anticipation!
statement 1)
q has x coordinate -30. that means if you start from (-30, 0) and trace up (above the x axis) there is a point, Q, on the circle at (-30,y), which will form line PQ. Similarly if you trace down below the x-axis, there is a point, Q at (-30, -y) on the circle, which will form line PQ. We don't need to solve for y. All we need to know is that we can solve for it. both lines from (-30,y) to (50,0) and (-30,-y) to (50,0) are equal in length. Sufficient.
statement 2)
q has y coodinate -40. that means if you start from (0,-40) and trace to the left of the y-axis, there is a point Q, on the circle at (-x,-40) which will form line PQ. Similarly if you trace to the right of y-axis, there is a point Q, on the circle at (x,-40) which will form line PQ. However, both of these lines have different lengths because one Q is closer to P than the other Q. Insufficient.
A is answer.
you got this, man!
- coderversion1
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 72
- Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2011 12:30 pm
- Thanked: 14 times
- Followed by:1 members
- GMAT Score:730
Anyone who thinks that answer should be E as O is not mentioned to be origin?
It would be improper to assume so.
It would be improper to assume so.