PS - gmatscore.com
This topic has expert replies
-
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 11:02 pm
(1)
(2M^3 + 2M) / 8 is an integer, doesn't mean much since anything multiplied by an even number is even, so,
2M^3 + 2M =
even*M^3 + even*M =
even + even = even
so (2M^3 + 2M) / 8 => even / even = integer doesn't help us know whether M is odd or even. So (1) is insufficient.
(2) M + 10 is divisible by 10, which must mean
M/10 + 10/10 is an integer.
M/10 + 1, so M/10 must be an integer, so M itself must mean it's a mutiple of 10, which is always even. Sufficient.
Answer is B.
(2M^3 + 2M) / 8 is an integer, doesn't mean much since anything multiplied by an even number is even, so,
2M^3 + 2M =
even*M^3 + even*M =
even + even = even
so (2M^3 + 2M) / 8 => even / even = integer doesn't help us know whether M is odd or even. So (1) is insufficient.
(2) M + 10 is divisible by 10, which must mean
M/10 + 10/10 is an integer.
M/10 + 1, so M/10 must be an integer, so M itself must mean it's a mutiple of 10, which is always even. Sufficient.
Answer is B.
-
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 11:02 pm
Actually, I take (1) back..
I just tried plugging the values in an excel spreadsheet, and only multiples of 4 for m seems to be divisible by 8, which WOULD allow us to answer that m is definitely not odd, making this answer selection D).
I'm now in the "help wanted" crowd for this problem as well
I just tried plugging the values in an excel spreadsheet, and only multiples of 4 for m seems to be divisible by 8, which WOULD allow us to answer that m is definitely not odd, making this answer selection D).
I'm now in the "help wanted" crowd for this problem as well
STMT 1: 2M(M+1) is divisible by 8
For M=4, 2.4.5 is divisible by 8
For M=3, 2.3.4 is also divisible by 8
Hence M can be even or odd and still satisfy stmt 1
Hence insuff
2) M + 10 is divisible by 10
only even numbers are divisible by 10
M+10 must be even. Therefore M must be even.
Hence we get an always NO for the question, Is M odd.
SUfficient
Hence B
For M=4, 2.4.5 is divisible by 8
For M=3, 2.3.4 is also divisible by 8
Hence M can be even or odd and still satisfy stmt 1
Hence insuff
2) M + 10 is divisible by 10
only even numbers are divisible by 10
M+10 must be even. Therefore M must be even.
Hence we get an always NO for the question, Is M odd.
SUfficient
Hence B
- jayhawk2001
- Community Manager
- Posts: 789
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 3:51 pm
- Location: Silicon valley, California
- Thanked: 30 times
- Followed by:1 members
My vote for D as well.
1 - sufficient.
2m (m^2 + 1) will be divisible by 8 when m is a multiple of 4.
For odd values of m, (m^2+1) will be divisible by 2 and when
multiplied by 2m, will not be divisible by 8.
So, sufficient to say that m cannot be odd.
2 - sufficient.
1 - sufficient.
2m (m^2 + 1) will be divisible by 8 when m is a multiple of 4.
For odd values of m, (m^2+1) will be divisible by 2 and when
multiplied by 2m, will not be divisible by 8.
So, sufficient to say that m cannot be odd.
2 - sufficient.
- f2001290
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 400
- Joined: Sat Mar 10, 2007 4:04 am
- Thanked: 1 times
- Followed by:1 members
I am confused .. B or D
Since 2(M^3) + 2M is divisible by 8 , I can say that this expression is even. In that case M can be odd or even.
But even JayHawk's approach appears right.
Since 2(M^3) + 2M is divisible by 8 , I can say that this expression is even. In that case M can be odd or even.
But even JayHawk's approach appears right.