1. If x,y,m and n are positive integers, where m>n, is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
2.If x and y are positive integers, m and n are integers, where m>n, is x^m/y^n>1
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
3.If x and y are non zero integers and m and n are positive integers, where m>n is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
4.If x,y and z are non zero integers, m and n are positive even integers, where m>n, is x^m*z/y^n>1?
(1)|z|>|x|>|y|
(2)x^m>y^n/z
Sorry but I don't have the OAs for any of them. Detailed explanations would be appreciated. Many Thanks.
4 Inequality DS Questions
This topic has expert replies
I disagree with GmatKiss on #3. IMO E
x & y are non zero integers, m & n are positive integers m>n
1.)x>y;
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m/y^n = 4/-3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m/y^n = 16/9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
2.)x^m>y^n
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m = 4, y^n = -3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m = 16, y^n = 9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
Combining these 2 statements yields no useful information (noted as we used the exact same data sets to show both statements are insufficient.)
Therefore, IMO E
x & y are non zero integers, m & n are positive integers m>n
1.)x>y;
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m/y^n = 4/-3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m/y^n = 16/9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
2.)x^m>y^n
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m = 4, y^n = -3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m = 16, y^n = 9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
Combining these 2 statements yields no useful information (noted as we used the exact same data sets to show both statements are insufficient.)
Therefore, IMO E
[/quote]GmatKiss wrote:3.If x and y are non zero integers and m and n are positive integers, where m>n is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^n
IMO:B
[/quote]HeintzC2 wrote:I disagree with GmatKiss on #3. IMO E
x & y are non zero integers, m & n are positive integers m>n
1.)x>y;
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m/y^n = 4/-3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m/y^n = 16/9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
2.)x^m>y^n
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 2, n = 1. x^m = 4, y^n = -3, x^m/y^n < 1
-choose x = -2, y = -3, also choose m = 4, n = 2. x^m = 16, y^n = 9, x^m/y^n > 1
insufficient.
Combining these 2 statements yields no useful information (noted as we used the exact same data sets to show both statements are insufficient.)
Therefore, IMO E
GmatKiss wrote:3.If x and y are non zero integers and m and n are positive integers, where m>n is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^n
IMO:B
Actual Question is : 3.If x and y are non zero integers and m and n are positive integers, where m>n is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
Ans is C!
By using the statement 1, we can conclude statement 2, X^m > y^m ...that's sufficient to ans.
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1448
- Joined: Tue May 17, 2011 9:55 am
- Location: India
- Thanked: 375 times
- Followed by:53 members
Hi,n@resh wrote: Actual Question is : 3.If x and y are non zero integers and m and n are positive integers, where m>n is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
Ans is C!
By using the statement 1, we can conclude statement 2, X^m > y^m ...that's sufficient to ans.
The question has been changed one day after HeintzC2 posted. Earlier, statement(2) was x^m>y^n.
Anyway, coming to the modified version of Q3, I don't think it is C.
From(1):
if x=2, y=1, m=2,n=1, x^m/y^n = 4>1
if x=2, y=-1, m=2,n=1, x^m/y^n = -4<1
Not sufficient
From(2):
Use the same set
Not sufficient
Both(1) and (2):
Same set
Not sufficient
Hence, E
Cheers!
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1448
- Joined: Tue May 17, 2011 9:55 am
- Location: India
- Thanked: 375 times
- Followed by:53 members
From(1):1. If x,y,m and n are positive integers, where m>n, is x^m/y^n>1?
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
x>y
So, x^m > y^m
m>n. So, y^m >= y^n
So, x^m > y^n
Sufficient
From(2):
x^m > y^m
As m>n, y^m >= y^n.
So, x^m > y^n
Sufficient
Hence, D
Cheers!
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1448
- Joined: Tue May 17, 2011 9:55 am
- Location: India
- Thanked: 375 times
- Followed by:53 members
From(1):2.If x and y are positive integers, m and n are integers, where m>n, is x^m/y^n>1
(1)x>y
(2)x^m>y^m
if x=2, y=1, m=2, n=1, x^m/y^n = 4>1
if x=2, y=1, m=-1 n=-2, x^m/y^n = 1/2<1
Not Sufficient
From(2):
x^m>y^m
As y>0, and m>n
y^m >= y^n
So, x^m > y^n
As y is positive, y^n is always positive.
So, multiplying by 1/y^n will not change sign.
So, x^m/y^n > 1
Sufficient
Hence, B
Last edited by Frankenstein on Thu Aug 25, 2011 8:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Cheers!
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1448
- Joined: Tue May 17, 2011 9:55 am
- Location: India
- Thanked: 375 times
- Followed by:53 members
From(1):4.If x,y and z are non zero integers, m and n are positive even integers, where m>n, is x^m*z/y^n>1?
(1)|z|>|x|>|y|
(2)x^m>y^n/z
if x=2,y=1,z=4, m=4,n=2, x^m*z/y^n = 2^16>1
if x=2,y=1,z=-4, m=4,n=2, x^m*z/y^n = 2^-16<1
Not sufficient
From(2):
Same set
Not sufficient
Both (1)and (2):
Not sufficient
Hence, E
I hope I haven't made any silly mistakes in my posts. If I have made any, please let me know.
Cheers!
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise
Things are not what they appear to be... nor are they otherwise