I will go with (A)
Question gives:
R = 1 + 2xy + x^2*y^2
Factor this to get
R = (1 + xy)(1 + xy) = (1 + xy)^2
Statement 1:
If R = 0, then either of the factors have to equal zero (and note that there is only one factor)
that means that xy = -1
Sufficient -> you know the answer.
Statement 2:
x is positive
Insufficient - this doesn't give you any indication of R or Y (or a real number for x)
No need to proceed any further and put them together, (A) was sufficient and (B) was not... there the answer is (A)
gmat prep xy
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |












