Sentence Correction

Popular child psychologists have advocated that parents discipline male children similarly to the fashion in which they discipline daughters.

similarly to the fashion in which they discipline
in the same manner that they would use with
like they would handle
as they discipline
as they would

[spoiler]Please don't spam with only "Answers". It is good for none; instead, a good explanation will be highly appreciated.[/spoiler]

IMO D

A :- correct but not concised "SIMILARLY TO THE FASHION" can be replaces with AS
B :- Wordy, USe of would is incorrect and changes the meaning.

Also, i think that the use of the IN THE SAME MANNER Is incorrect because it is the literal meaning of LIKE and we cannot use like to compare clauses.

C :- LIKE can not be used, Use of would is incorrect.

E :- incorrect use of would.

OA and OE please

imskpwr wrote:Popular child psychologists have advocated that parents discipline male children similarly to the fashion in which they discipline daughters.

similarly to the fashion in which they discipline
in the same manner that they would use with
like they would handle
as they discipline
as they would

[spoiler]Please don't spam with only "Answers". It is good for none; instead, a good explanation will be highly appreciated.[/spoiler]

shekhar.kataria wrote:IMO D

A :- correct but not concised "SIMILARLY TO THE FASHION" can be replaces with AS
B :- Wordy, USe of would is incorrect and changes the meaning.

Also, i think that the use of the IN THE SAME MANNER Is incorrect because it is the literal meaning of LIKE and we cannot use like to compare clauses.

C :- LIKE can not be used, Use of would is incorrect.

E :- incorrect use of would.

OA and OE please

imskpwr wrote:Popular child psychologists have advocated that parents discipline male children similarly to the fashion in which they discipline daughters.

similarly to the fashion in which they discipline
in the same manner that they would use with
like they would handle
as they discipline
as they would

[spoiler]Please don't spam with only "Answers". It is good for none; instead, a good explanation will be highly appreciated.[/spoiler]

OA and source after some discussion.

hi,
in kaplan verbal book it is written that the OA is E
I found D.
do not understand the use of would.....

To experts:
please help on this

OA and OE please ????