Let S = (33!/1 + 33!/2 + 33!/3 + ..... + 33!/32 + 33!/33).
What will be remainder when S is divided by 29?
(A) 1
(B) 5
(C) 24
(D) 28
(E) None of the above
OA will be given later.
Remainder from Sum containing Factorial
This topic has expert replies
As nobody has posted any solution, I am giving first hint.
Hint 1: Please note that S = (33!/1 + 33!/2 + 33!/3 + ..... + 33!/32 + 33!/33).
When you divide each term by 29, you will find that every term is divisible by 29 except 33!/29. For example 33!/1/29 is divisible by 29. Similarly, 33!/2/29 is also divisible by 29. The only term which is not divisible is 33!/29 because it has already 29 as denominator. So, practically speaking, you need to find remainder when (33!/29) is divided by 29. So, now, instead of 33 terms, you are dealing with only one term.
Note: I hope, many viewers will be able to find solution with the above hint. If I don't get solution in another 12 hours, I shall post second hint.
Hint 1: Please note that S = (33!/1 + 33!/2 + 33!/3 + ..... + 33!/32 + 33!/33).
When you divide each term by 29, you will find that every term is divisible by 29 except 33!/29. For example 33!/1/29 is divisible by 29. Similarly, 33!/2/29 is also divisible by 29. The only term which is not divisible is 33!/29 because it has already 29 as denominator. So, practically speaking, you need to find remainder when (33!/29) is divided by 29. So, now, instead of 33 terms, you are dealing with only one term.
Note: I hope, many viewers will be able to find solution with the above hint. If I don't get solution in another 12 hours, I shall post second hint.
-
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 2630
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2012 3:32 pm
- Location: East Bay all the way
- Thanked: 625 times
- Followed by:119 members
- GMAT Score:780
Every term other than 33!/29 will still have a 29 in its numerator, so every term other than 33!/29 is divisible by 29.
That means that problem can be stated as
(33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(24 * 28!) mod 29
From here, I'd use Wilson's Theorem, which is not at all appropriate for the GMAT (but then again, neither is this question). Since 29 is prime, we know that 28! mod 29 = -1. That means the answer we seek is (24 * -1) mod 29, or 5.
That means that problem can be stated as
(33*32*31*30*28*27*...*1) mod 29 =>What is the remainder when 33!/29 is divided by 29?
(33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(24 * 28!) mod 29
From here, I'd use Wilson's Theorem, which is not at all appropriate for the GMAT (but then again, neither is this question). Since 29 is prime, we know that 28! mod 29 = -1. That means the answer we seek is (24 * -1) mod 29, or 5.
Superb, Matt. You are wonderful and your answer is correct except one small mistake:Matt@VeritasPrep wrote:Every term other than 33!/29 will still have a 29 in its numerator, so every term other than 33!/29 is divisible by 29.
That means that problem can be stated as
(33*32*31*30*28*27*...*1) mod 29 =>What is the remainder when 33!/29 is divided by 29?
(33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
(24 * 28!) mod 29
From here, I'd use Wilson's Theorem, which is not at all appropriate for the GMAT (but then again, neither is this question). Since 29 is prime, we know that 28! mod 29 = -1. That means the answer we seek is (24 * -1) mod 29, or 5.
(33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 is not equal to (-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
Rather, it should be (4*3*2*1*28!) mod 29.
Rest is all right.
-
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 2630
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2012 3:32 pm
- Location: East Bay all the way
- Thanked: 625 times
- Followed by:119 members
- GMAT Score:780
Ah, but that isn't a mistake! It'd be a mistake to say that 33 = -4 mod 29, but that isn't what I saidpannalal wrote: (33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 is not equal to (-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
Rather, it should be (4*3*2*1*28!) mod 29.
Of course, I could see why it would seem that way from what I typed, but hey, I'm wriggling out of this one.
Matt, somehow, I still feel that there is a mistake. If you write:Matt@VeritasPrep wrote:Ah, but that isn't a mistake! It'd be a mistake to say that 33 = -4 mod 29, but that isn't what I saidpannalal wrote: (33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 is not equal to (-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29 =>
Rather, it should be (4*3*2*1*28!) mod 29.
Of course, I could see why it would seem that way from what I typed, but hey, I'm wriggling out of this one.
(33*32*31*30 * 28!) mod 29 = (-4 * -3 * -2 * -1 * 28!) mod 29
How do you prove that you are right. The final answer is correct because 4*3*2*1 = 24 and (-4)*(-3)*(-2)*(-1) = 24. Somehow I am not ready to accept that it is not a mistake. In any case, please state how do you arrive (33*32*31*30) mod 29 = (-4 * -3 * -2 * -1) mod 29.