Sentence Correction

Q) When the Calvinists could not agree with the established religious doctrine, they both broke with the Roman Catholic Church, which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and with the Lutherans, differing from their fellow Protestants on the doctrines of Communion and other theories of worship.

(A) which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and with the Lutherans, differing
(B) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and the Lutherans, who differed
(C) which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and abandoned the Lutherans, who differed
(D) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and abandoned the Lutherans, differing
(E) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and also abandoned the Lutherans, who differed

Really liked this one!

OA D

Thank you Rich.. what I had missed was the parallelism between broke and abandoned. Maybe not interpreting the sentence correctly was the problem !

I eliminated D because of (,+-ing) "who" is much more suitable to refer to the Lutherans.The -ing participle modifies the action of the previous clause and refers to the subject of the previous clause which is the Calvinists.
Not the intended meaning
Please correct me if my reasoning is wrong.

Hi Aman,

The usage of 'who' here is implied because 'who' cannot be added along with the participle 'differing'. The noun closest to differing is Lutherans and in this case will not directly refer to Calvinists.

To make the participle 'resulting', from the first clause, parallel to the second clause, you will have to use differing.

In your case 'C' would be apt but the clauses again are not parallel as the first refers to the object i.e The act of breaking whereas the second clause would refer to the subject i.e Lutherans.

gmatcracker0123 wrote:Q) When the Calvinists could not agree with the established religious doctrine, they both broke with the Roman Catholic Church, which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and with the Lutherans, differing from their fellow Protestants on the doctrines of Communion and other theories of worship.

(A) which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and with the Lutherans, differing
(B) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and the Lutherans, who differed
(C) which resulted in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and abandoned the Lutherans, who differed
(D) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and abandoned the Lutherans, differing
(E) resulting in the Religious Wars of the 16th century, and also abandoned the Lutherans, who differed

OA D

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

The correct response is (D). The word "both" earlier in the sentence comes before the verb "broke", meaning that the second portion of that structure, after "and", must come with its own verb to be parallel. Choices A and B fail to supply such a verb, and are therefore wrong.

Choices A and C commit another error, using the relative pronoun "which" to start the modifier "which resulted in the Religious Wars" - that modifier needs to describe the action of the Calvinists breaking with the Roman Catholic Church, not the church itself, so the participial modifier "resulting" is necessary.

Choice E commits a redundancy error with the word "also" - since the structure is already set up for "both broke...and abandoned", so "also" is superfluous and incorrect. The correct answer is D.