College professor: College students do not write nearly as well as they used to. Almost all of the papers that my students have done for me this year have been poorly written and ungrammatical.
Which one of the following is the most serious weakness in the argument made by the professor?
(A) It requires confirmation that the change in the professor's students is representative of a change among college students in general.
(B) It offers no proof to the effect that the professor is an accurate judge of writing ability.
(C) It does not take into account the possibility that the professor is a poor teacher.
(D) It fails to present contrary evidence.
(E) It fails to define its terms sufficiently.
OA after discussion
College Professor Poor Writing Question , Please help!
This topic has expert replies
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2010 8:51 pm
- Thanked: 62 times
- Followed by:5 members
- GMAT Score:750
1. The Professors students this year do not write well
2. All students dont write as well as they used to
A. Correct. The assumption the professor makes in his argument is that his class is representative of all college students. We do not know if that is true without evaluating other students. It might just be that he has a class of poor students.
B. Incorrect. The professor is making a comparison between students this year and last year. Even if he is a poor judge he was still a poor judge in the past making the comparison relevant.
C. Incorrect. The professors teaching has nothing to do with the writing ability of his students.
D. Incorrect. Irrelevant
E. Incorrect. The passage is very clear.
2. All students dont write as well as they used to
A. Correct. The assumption the professor makes in his argument is that his class is representative of all college students. We do not know if that is true without evaluating other students. It might just be that he has a class of poor students.
B. Incorrect. The professor is making a comparison between students this year and last year. Even if he is a poor judge he was still a poor judge in the past making the comparison relevant.
C. Incorrect. The professors teaching has nothing to do with the writing ability of his students.
D. Incorrect. Irrelevant
E. Incorrect. The passage is very clear.
-
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2010 2:00 am
- Thanked: 2 times
i agree with "fitz" as this is a classic case of "hasty generalization"...the professor assumes that his class is representative of the entire core group....to weaken it we simply have to prove this assumption wrongcyrwr1 wrote:College professor: College students do not write nearly as well as they used to. Almost all of the papers that my students have done for me this year have been poorly written and ungrammatical.
Which one of the following is the most serious weakness in the argument made by the professor?
(A) It requires confirmation that the change in the professor's students is representative of a change among college students in general.
(B) It offers no proof to the effect that the professor is an accurate judge of writing ability.
(C) It does not take into account the possibility that the professor is a poor teacher.
(D) It fails to present contrary evidence.
(E) It fails to define its terms sufficiently.
OA after discussion
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1112
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2011 11:16 am
- Thanked: 77 times
- Followed by:49 members
-
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 2330
- Joined: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:14 am
- Thanked: 56 times
- Followed by:26 members
Can You cite the source plscyrwr1 wrote:College professor: College students do not write nearly as well as they used to. Almost all of the papers that my students have done for me this year have been poorly written and ungrammatical.
Which one of the following is the most serious weakness in the argument made by the professor?
(A) It requires confirmation that the change in the professor's students is representative of a change among college students in general.
(B) It offers no proof to the effect that the professor is an accurate judge of writing ability.
(C) It does not take into account the possibility that the professor is a poor teacher.
(D) It fails to present contrary evidence.
(E) It fails to define its terms sufficiently.
OA after discussion
I Seek Explanations Not Answers
Thanks Fitzgerald23 and others for chiming in.
This was a careless response on my part. I chose B. I should have reread choice 1 as this is a classic example of using subset to represent a group.
OA is A and this is from the Aristotle CR 100.
Thanks,
Cyrus
This was a careless response on my part. I chose B. I should have reread choice 1 as this is a classic example of using subset to represent a group.
OA is A and this is from the Aristotle CR 100.
Thanks,
Cyrus