In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and of all the other planets, each contributing according to their mass and distance from others.
a.
b. of all the other planets, with each of them contributing according to their
c. all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
e. all the other planets, each of which contribute according to their.
GMAT 2.0
This topic has expert replies
GMAT/MBA Expert
- Mike@Magoosh
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 4:18 pm
- Location: Berkeley, CA
- Thanked: 387 times
- Followed by:140 members
Hi, there. I'm happy to help with this.fangtray wrote:In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and of all the other planets, each contributing according to their mass and distance from others.
a.
b. of all the other planets, with each of them contributing according to their
c. all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
e. all the other planets, each of which contribute according to their.
First of all, the pronoun "each" is always singular, so the answers that pair "each" (singular) with "their" (plural) are incorrect. That immediately eliminates (A), (B), and (E).
The problem with (C) is ---- the relative pronoun "which" is supposed to introduce a relative clause, with it's own noun + verb. Instead, in (C), "which" is followed by a participial phrase, "contributing . . ." That's grammatically incorrect. It's also unnecessarily wordy.
That leaves [spoiler](D)[/spoiler] ---- compact, direct, and free of errors ---- the correct answer.
Does all this make sense? Please let me know if you have any more questions.
Mike
Last edited by Mike@Magoosh on Mon May 07, 2012 10:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
Magoosh GMAT Instructor
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 273
- Joined: Thu Sep 08, 2011 6:50 am
- Thanked: 5 times
- Followed by:3 members
thx mike! i chose between c and d as well. could you explain why which needs to be followed by its own noun + verb? and an example of what could be done to C, so that which is correctly used?Mike@Magoosh wrote:Hi, there. I'm happy to help with this.fangtray wrote:In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and of all the other planets, each contributing according to their mass and distance from others.
a.
b. of all the other planets, with each of them contributing according to their
c. all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
e. all the other planets, each of which contribute according to their.
First of all, the pronoun "each" is always singular, so the answers that pair "each" (singular) with "their" (plural) are incorrect. That immediately eliminates (A), (B), and (E).
The problem with (C) is ---- the relative pronoun "which" is supposed to introduce a relative clause, with it's own noun + verb. Instead, in (C), "which" is followed by a participial phrase, "contributing . . ." That's grammatically incorrect. It's also unnecessarily wordy.
That leaves [spoiler](D)[/spoiler] ---- compact, direct, and free of errors ---- the correct answer.
Here's a free lesson on pronouns that you may find helpful.
https://gmat.magoosh.com/lessons/613-pronouns-i
Does all this make sense? Please let me know if you have any more questions.
Mike
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 273
- Joined: Thu Sep 08, 2011 6:50 am
- Thanked: 5 times
- Followed by:3 members
thx mike! i chose between c and d as well. could you explain why which needs to be followed by its own noun + verb? and an example of what could be done to C, so that which is correctly used?Mike@Magoosh wrote:Hi, there. I'm happy to help with this.fangtray wrote:In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and of all the other planets, each contributing according to their mass and distance from others.
a.
b. of all the other planets, with each of them contributing according to their
c. all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
e. all the other planets, each of which contribute according to their.
First of all, the pronoun "each" is always singular, so the answers that pair "each" (singular) with "their" (plural) are incorrect. That immediately eliminates (A), (B), and (E).
The problem with (C) is ---- the relative pronoun "which" is supposed to introduce a relative clause, with it's own noun + verb. Instead, in (C), "which" is followed by a participial phrase, "contributing . . ." That's grammatically incorrect. It's also unnecessarily wordy.
That leaves [spoiler](D)[/spoiler] ---- compact, direct, and free of errors ---- the correct answer.
Here's a free lesson on pronouns that you may find helpful.
https://gmat.magoosh.com/lessons/613-pronouns-i
Does all this make sense? Please let me know if you have any more questions.
Mike
GMAT/MBA Expert
- Mike@Magoosh
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 4:18 pm
- Location: Berkeley, CA
- Thanked: 387 times
- Followed by:140 members
Dear fantray,fangtray wrote:thx mike! i chose between c and d as well. could you explain why which needs to be followed by its own noun + verb? and an example of what could be done to C, so that which is correctly used?
Why does "which" need to be followed by a noun + verb? Well, how well do you understand independent and dependent clauses? Unlike a participial phrase ("contributing according to its ..."), any clause, whether independent or dependent, need to have a noun & verb. Dependent clauses are introduced by subordinate conjunctions (e.g. after, although, as, as far as, as if, as long as, as soon as, as though, because, before, if, in order that, since, so, so that, than, though, unless, until, when, whenever, where, whereas, wherever, and while) or a relative pronoun (e.g. who, what, which, where, when, why). These are huge topics in grammar --- I don't think there's any way I could say everything there is to say about them in a single post. Here's a free lesson on SC
https://gmat.magoosh.com/lessons/600-gen ... strategies
but I would recommend some source that would give you a thorough overview of the grammar on the GMAT. Magoosh has an excellent series of videos covering all this grammar. See the link in my signature.
As far as what would make C acceptable . . . here is the current version of (C)
(C) In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its mass and distance from others.
Here's the corrected version --- change the participle to a verb -----
(C) In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, each of which contributes according to its mass and distance from others..
The relative pronoun "which" acts as the noun and "contributes" is a bonafide verb.
Does that make sense?
Let me know if you have any further questions.
Mike
Magoosh GMAT Instructor
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 273
- Joined: Thu Sep 08, 2011 6:50 am
- Thanked: 5 times
- Followed by:3 members
omg thanks so much for that explanation. since which is part of a dependent clause, it is the noun. and it needs a verb. So each of WHICH contributes..Mike@Magoosh wrote:Dear fantray,fangtray wrote:thx mike! i chose between c and d as well. could you explain why which needs to be followed by its own noun + verb? and an example of what could be done to C, so that which is correctly used?
Why does "which" need to be followed by a noun + verb? Well, how well do you understand independent and dependent clauses? Unlike a participial phrase ("contributing according to its ..."), any clause, whether independent or dependent, need to have a noun & verb. Dependent clauses are introduced by subordinate conjunctions (e.g. after, although, as, as far as, as if, as long as, as soon as, as though, because, before, if, in order that, since, so, so that, than, though, unless, until, when, whenever, where, whereas, wherever, and while) or a relative pronoun (e.g. who, what, which, where, when, why). These are huge topics in grammar --- I don't think there's any way I could say everything there is to say about them in a single post. Here's a free lesson on SC
https://gmat.magoosh.com/lessons/600-gen ... strategies
but I would recommend some source that would give you a thorough overview of the grammar on the GMAT. Magoosh has an excellent series of videos covering all this grammar. See the link in my signature.
As far as what would make C acceptable . . . here is the current version of (C)
(C) In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, each of which contributing according to its mass and distance from others.
Here's the corrected version --- change the participle to a verb -----
(C) In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, each of which contributes according to its mass and distance from others..
The relative pronoun "which" acts as the noun and "contributes" is a bonafide verb.
Does that make sense?
Let me know if you have any further questions.
Mike
or we can even say, Each of WHICH IS contributing right? Is will be the verb in this case?
-
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 418
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 12:48 pm
- Thanked: 6 times
- Followed by:3 members
Hi Mike@magoosh,
Please what do you think would determine the best answer if C and D
were:
c. all the other planets, all contributing according to their
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
i.e "all....their" Vs "each...its"
Please what do you think would determine the best answer if C and D
were:
c. all the other planets, all contributing according to their
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
i.e "all....their" Vs "each...its"
GMAT/MBA Expert
- Mike@Magoosh
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 4:18 pm
- Location: Berkeley, CA
- Thanked: 387 times
- Followed by:140 members
The construction ...fangtray wrote:omg thanks so much for that explanation. since which is part of a dependent clause, it is the noun. and it needs a verb. So each of WHICH contributes..
or we can even say, Each of WHICH IS contributing right? Is will be the verb in this case?
each of which contributes according to its mass and distance from others.
... uses the regular present tense, which is perfectly correct.
The construction ...
each of which is contributing according to its mass and distance from others.
... use the present progressive. The present progressive emphasizes that the action is question is taking place simultaneously with our description of it. "She talks to her friend on the phone" --- general present tense indicates merely that this is a regular occurrence, a typical recurring situation. "She is talking to her friend on the phone" --- the present progressive indicates that right now, right at this moment, she is performing this action, simultaneous with our description of it.
In this context, the planets are out their doing their gravitational thing, but there's absolutely no reason to emphasize that their action is exactly simultaneous with our description of it. That's why the present progressive would be incorrect. Yes, in the very narrow sense of providing a noun for the clause following "which" --- in that limited sense, it is correct, but overall, it does not fit the logic of the sentence.
Does that make sense?
Mike
Magoosh GMAT Instructor
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
GMAT/MBA Expert
- Mike@Magoosh
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 4:18 pm
- Location: Berkeley, CA
- Thanked: 387 times
- Followed by:140 members
That's a great question, gmatdriller. I'm happy to answer.gmatdriller wrote:Hi Mike@magoosh,
Please what do you think would determine the best answer if C and D
were:
c. all the other planets, all contributing according to their
d. all the other planets, each contributing according to its
i.e "all....their" Vs "each...its"
Let's go back to the original sentence with correct answer (D)
In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, each contributing according to its mass and distance from others.
You propose an alternate to (C):
In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, all contributing according to their mass and distance from others.
Yes, now we have agreement between "all" and "their", so that's no longer a problem. One problem that remains is: "their" refers to all the planets, but "mass and distance" are singular. Not all th planets have the same mass. Each has a unique mass. Therefore, we would need those words in the plural.
In his experiments with gravity, Isaac Newton showed how the motion of each planet in the solar system results from the combined gravitational pull of the Sun and all the other planets, all contributing according to their masses and distances from others.
This version is technically grammatically correct, insofar as all the singulars & plurals match up correctly. The problem is more subtle, about the logic of the sentence. We want to emphasize the complexity of Newton's model --- the motion of any one planet depends on the Sun's gravity and on the gravity from each other planet. Say we are looking at Mars and its orbit --- the Sun's gravity has one impact, Earth's gravity on Mars has another impact, Jupiter's gravity on Mars has yet another impact, etc. etc. The orbit of Mars depends on all the different impacts. Each planet has a unique impact on each other planet: that is the nature of the complexity of the Newtonian model.
The construction "each contributing according to its" captures the particularity of the interactions, whereas "all contributing according to their" lumps everything together in way that might obscure the full complexity. Therefore, the "each" version is better than the "all" version. BTW, this final distinction is, in all likelihood, more subtle that the GMAT SC would address.
Does that make sense? Let me know if you have any further questions.
Mike
Magoosh GMAT Instructor
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
https://gmat.magoosh.com/
- richachampion
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 698
- Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2015 12:12 am
- Location: Noida, India
- Thanked: 32 times
- Followed by:26 members
- GMAT Score:740
In option E:
each of which contribute(plural) = that means "which" is referring to planets and that makes perfect sense with the plural verb "contribute".
Please justify my understanding?
each of which contribute(plural) = that means "which" is referring to planets and that makes perfect sense with the plural verb "contribute".
Please justify my understanding?
R I C H A,
My GMAT Journey: 470 → 720 → 740
Target Score: 760+
[email protected]
1. Press thanks if you like my solution.
2. Contact me if you are not improving. (No Free Lunch!)
My GMAT Journey: 470 → 720 → 740
Target Score: 760+
[email protected]
1. Press thanks if you like my solution.
2. Contact me if you are not improving. (No Free Lunch!)
- DavidG@VeritasPrep
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 2663
- Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2015 8:25 am
- Location: Boston, MA
- Thanked: 1153 times
- Followed by:128 members
- GMAT Score:770
"Which" is the object of the preposition "of," rather than the subject of the verb "contribute." "Each" is the subject of the verb, and "each" is singular.richachampion wrote:In option E:
each of which contribute(plural) = that means "which" is referring to planets and that makes perfect sense with the plural verb "contribute".
Please justify my understanding?