OG RC Question #7

This topic has expert replies
Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 3
Joined: Sat Jul 04, 2015 2:10 pm

OG RC Question #7

by happyface101 » Sat Jul 04, 2015 2:14 pm
Ecoefficiency (measures to minimize environmental impact through the reduction or elimination of waste from production processes) has become a goal for companies worldwide, with many realizing significant cost savings from such innovations. Peter Senge and Goran Carstedt see this development as laudable but suggest that simply adopting ecoefficiency innovations could actually worsen environmental stresses in the future. Such innovations reduce production waste but do not alter the number of products manufactured nor the waste generated from their use and discard; indeed, most companies invest in ecoefficiency improvements in order to increase profits and growth. Moreover, there is no guarantee that increased economic growth from ecoefficiency will come in similarly ecoefficient ways, since in today's global markets, greater profits may be turned into investment capital that could easily be reinvested in old-style eco-inefficient industries. Even a vastly more ecoefficient industrial system could, were it to grow much larger, generate more total waste and destroy more habitat and species than would a smaller, less ecoefficient economy. Senge and Carstedt argue that to preserve the global environment and sustain economic growth, businesses must develop a new systemic approach that reduces total material use and total accumulated waste. Focusing exclusively on ecoefficiency, which offers a compelling business case according to established thinking, may distract companies from pursuing radically different products and business models.

Q7:The passage implies that which of the following is a possible consequence of a company's adoption of innovations that increase its ecoefficiency?

A. Company profits resulting from such innovations may be reinvested in that company with no guarantee that the company will continue to make further improvements in ecoefficiency.

B. Company growth fostered by cost savings from such innovations may allow that company to manufacture a greater number of products that will be used and discarded, thus worsening environmental stress.

C. A company that fails to realize significant cost savings from such innovations may have little incentive to continue to minimize the environmental impact of its production processes.

D. A company that comes to depend on such innovations to increase its profits and growth may be vulnerable in the global market to competition from old-style ecoinefficient industries.

E. A company that meets its ecoefficiency goals is unlikely to invest its increased profits in the development of new and innovative ecoefficiency measures.

--

The correct answer is B. I can see that B is a good answer, but it seems that so is A. I'm confused as why A is not right because it's just a rephrasing of this sentence in the passage no? "Moreover, there is no guarantee that increased economic growth from ecoefficiency will come in similarly ecoefficient ways, since in today's global markets, greater profits may be turned into investment capital that could easily be reinvested in old-style eco-inefficient industries"

Thanks!

User avatar
Legendary Member
Posts: 2131
Joined: Mon Feb 03, 2014 9:26 am
Location: https://martymurraycoaching.com/
Thanked: 955 times
Followed by:140 members
GMAT Score:800

by MartyMurray » Tue Jul 07, 2015 6:42 pm
happyface101 wrote:The correct answer is B. I can see that B is a good answer, but it seems that so is A. I'm confused as why A is not right because it's just a rephrasing of this sentence in the passage no? "Moreover, there is no guarantee that increased economic growth from ecoefficiency will come in similarly ecoefficient ways, since in today's global markets, greater profits may be turned into investment capital that could easily be reinvested in old-style eco-inefficient industries"
A is different from the sentence you are quoting.

A is saying something specific, that a company may invest profits derived from ecoefficiency back into that same company, and the problem is that the company may not continue to make improvements in ecoefficiency.

The truth is that this is not among the concerns mentioned in the passage.

The sentence you quoted actually implies that the profits would not be reinvested in that same company. The author is saying that because of the global nature of today's markets, profits from an ecoefficiently run company could be invested in old-style industries. By mentioning the "global markets" the author is implying not that the profits will be invested into the same company, but rather that they will be invested elsewhere on the globe.
Marty Murray
Perfect Scoring Tutor With Over a Decade of Experience
MartyMurrayCoaching.com
Contact me at [email protected] for a free consultation.