This topic has expert replies
Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
Posts: 212
Joined: 06 Dec 2010
Location: India
Thanked: 5 times
Followed by:1 members

Inference in RC

by sachin_yadav » Tue Jun 03, 2014 7:49 pm
Diamonds are almost impossible to detect directly because they are so rare: very rich kimberlite pipes, the routes through which diamonds rise, may contain only three carats of diamonds per ton of kimberlite. Kimberlite begins as magma in Earth's mantle (the layer between the crust and the core). As the magma smashes through layers of rock, it rips out debris, creating a mix of liquid and solid material. Some of the solid material it brings up may come from a so-called diamond-stability field, where conditions of pressure and temperature are conducive to the formation of diamonds. If diamonds are to survive, though, they must shoot toward Earth's surface quickly. Otherwise, they revert to graphite or burn. Explorers seeking diamonds look for specks of "indicator minerals" peculiar to the mantle but carried up in greater quantities than diamonds and eroded out of kimberlite pipes into the surrounding land. The standard ones are garnets, chromites, and ilmenites. One can spend years searching for indicators and tracing them back to the pipes that are their source; however, 90 percent of kimberlite pipes found this way are barren of diamonds, and the rest are usually too sparse to mine.

In the 1970's the process of locating profitable pipes was refined by focusing on the subtle differences between the chemical signatures of indicator minerals found in diamond-rich pipes as opposed to those found in barren pipes. For example, G10 garnets, a type of garnet typically found in diamond-rich pipes, are lower in calcium and higher in chrome than garnets from barren pipes. Geochemists John Gurney showed that garnets with this composition were formed only in the diamond-stability field; more commonly found versions came from elsewhere in the mantle. Gurney also found that though ilmenites did not form in the diamond-stability field, there was a link useful for prospectors: when the iron in ilmenite was highly oxidized, its source pipe rarely contained any diamonds. He reasoned that iron took on more or less oxygen in response to conditions in the kimberlitic magma itself-mainly in response to heat and the available oxygen. When iron became highly oxidized, so did diamonds; that is, they vaporized into carbon dioxide.

The passage suggests that the presence of G10 garnet in a kimberlite pipe indicates that
(A)the pipe in which the garnet is found has a 90% chance of containing diamonds
(B)the levels of calcium and chrome in the pipe are conducive to diamond formation
(C)the pipe passed through a diamond-stability field and thus may contain diamonds
(D)any diamonds the pipe contains would not have come from the diamond-stability field
(E)the pipe's temperature was so high that it oxidized any diamonds the pipe might have contained

OA is C

Please explain the difference between B and C ?

Sachin
Never surrender

GMAT Instructor
Posts: 1035
Joined: 17 Dec 2010
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Thanked: 474 times
Followed by:364 members
by VivianKerr » Wed Jun 11, 2014 1:19 am
The word "suggests" indicates that this is an Inference question, so we'll need to 1) re-read the pertinent info in the passage and try to make a prediction, and 2) select the answer choice that is closest to the tiny details from the passage.

Where is "presence of G10 garnet in a kimberlite pipe" mentioned?

I see it in the second paragraph: ...the process of locating profitable pipes was refined by focusing on the subtle differences between the chemical signatures of indicator minerals found in diamond-rich pipes as opposed to those found in barren pipes. For example, G10 garnets, a type of garnet typically found in diamond-rich pipes, are lower in calcium and higher in chrome than garnets from barren pipes. Geochemists John Gurney showed that garnets with this composition were formed only in the diamond-stability field.

So, what does LOW calcium/HIGH chrome indicate? Probably a profitable pipe!

Prediction: $The correct answer is (C). It's not (B), because we can't say for certain it's the calcium/chrome that is CAUSING the diamonds. The passage only supports a correlative relationship. (See your CR skills coming to your aid on the RC!) Vivian Kerr GMAT Rockstar, Tutor https://www.GMATrockstar.com https://www.yelp.com/biz/gmat-rockstar-los-angeles Former Kaplan and Grockit instructor, freelance GMAT content creator, now offering affordable, effective, Skype-tutoring for the GMAT at$150/hr. Contact: [email protected]

Thank you for all the "thanks" and "follows"!

Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
Posts: 116
Joined: 14 Mar 2012
Thanked: 20 times
Followed by:11 members
GMAT Score:760
by mcdesty » Fri Jul 11, 2014 6:05 am
sachin_yadav wrote:Diamonds are almost impossible to detect directly because they are so rare: very rich kimberlite pipes, the routes through which diamonds rise, may contain only three carats of diamonds per ton of kimberlite. Kimberlite begins as magma in Earth's mantle (the layer between the crust and the core). As the magma smashes through layers of rock, it rips out debris, creating a mix of liquid and solid material. Some of the solid material it brings up may come from a so-called diamond-stability field, where conditions of pressure and temperature are conducive to the formation of diamonds. If diamonds are to survive, though, they must shoot toward Earth's surface quickly. Otherwise, they revert to graphite or burn. Explorers seeking diamonds look for specks of "indicator minerals" peculiar to the mantle but carried up in greater quantities than diamonds and eroded out of kimberlite pipes into the surrounding land. The standard ones are garnets, chromites, and ilmenites. One can spend years searching for indicators and tracing them back to the pipes that are their source; however, 90 percent of kimberlite pipes found this way are barren of diamonds, and the rest are usually too sparse to mine.

In the 1970's the process of locating profitable pipes was refined by focusing on the subtle differences between the chemical signatures of indicator minerals found in diamond-rich pipes as opposed to those found in barren pipes. For example, G10 garnets, a type of garnet typically found in diamond-rich pipes, are lower in calcium and higher in chrome than garnets from barren pipes. Geochemists John Gurney showed that garnets with this composition(the G10 composition) were formed only in the diamond-stability field; more commonly found versions came from elsewhere in the mantle. Gurney also found that though ilmenites did not form in the diamond-stability field, there was a link useful for prospectors: when the iron in ilmenite was highly oxidized, its source pipe rarely contained any diamonds. He reasoned that iron took on more or less oxygen in response to conditions in the kimberlitic magma itself-mainly in response to heat and the available oxygen. When iron became highly oxidized, so did diamonds; that is, they vaporized into carbon dioxide.

The passage suggests that the presence of G10 garnet in a kimberlite pipe indicates that
(A)the pipe in which the garnet is found has a 90% chance of containing diamonds
(B)the levels of calcium and chrome in the pipe are conducive to diamond formation
(C)the pipe passed through a diamond-stability field and thus may contain diamonds
(D)any diamonds the pipe contains would not have come from the diamond-stability field
(E)the pipe's temperature was so high that it oxidized any diamonds the pipe might have contained

OA is C
Please explain the difference between B and C ?

The passage says that G10 garnets are lower in calcium and higher in chrome than garnets from barren pipes. (see portion highlighted in red)

The passage doesn't say that the presence of G10 garnet in a kimberlite pipe indicates that the levels of calcium and chrome in the pipe are conducive to diamond formation.

See highlighted portion in Green that confirms C.

Sentence correction in action here; Know how to eliminate modifiers to get to the core of the sentence.

Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
Posts: 33
Joined: 20 Dec 2018
by masoom j negi » Sat Dec 22, 2018 2:46 am
"G10 garnets, a type of garnet typically found in diamond-rich pipes, are lower in calcium and higher in chrome than garnets from barren pipes. Geochemist John Gurney showed that garnets with this composition were formed only in the diamond-stability field;" These lines from the second paragraph of the passage clearly suggest that the presence of G-10 garnet in the kimberlite pipe suggests the presence of diamond. Hence, C is the answer.

• Page 1 of 1