Veritas( transit privatization)

This topic has expert replies
Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
Posts: 120
Joined: 05 Dec 2015

Veritas( transit privatization)

by gocoder » Thu Dec 01, 2016 6:58 pm
Transit privatization is highly controversial, with proponents claiming great potential benefits and detractors pointing to cases where privatization has been very problematic. One critical consideration in this argument is the concept of merit good. The rationale behind this concept is that governments should guarantee basic service in public transportation to deprived customer groups despite the fact that it is economically irrational.

Today, the question among most observers is not whether public transportation should be subsidized, but what the optimal level of subsidy should be. All public transportation systems need some degree of subsidy to run, but some are more privatized than others. The U.S. air transportation system is an example where "privatization" has worked well: very little government subsidy goes to the airlines, but tickets are both inexpensive and readily available.

However, in markets where there is no economic incentive for airlines to fly, the government has instituted a program called Essential Air Service. Unlike airline privatization as a whole, this program, a holdover from the days of bloated airline regulation, has been a disastrous example of overspending and inefficiency. Across Alaska and many other rural states like Maine and North Dakota, airports and airlines are subsidized so that unprofitable routes are flown in the name of "merit good." However, in most of these places, airports are neither required nor important to deprived customer groups; they are simply an economic boon to important special interest groups that support congressmen and senators.

While there is a place for subsidy and even direct government involvement beyond the required minimum - when true merit good issues are concerned - most transportation systems are better today after privatization than they were in the days of total government control. All you need to do is look at the "Essential Air Service" program to understand the wastefulness and inefficiency that existed in the 60's and 70's when most public transportation systems were under full government control.

The author uses quotations around the word "privatization" in the second paragraph in order to:

A. show that the airlines are still really government controlled.

B.highlight how little the airlines have really been privatized

C. emphasize that the airlines are not completely privatized.

D.emphasize how poorly the privatization process has worked. his view on the privatization process in public transportation.

I can't see why the the author is not supporting the privatization of transport.
What is flaw in E here ? Please help.

User avatar
Legendary Member
Posts: 2075
Joined: 03 Feb 2014
Location: New York City Metro Area and Worldwide Online
Thanked: 955 times
Followed by:138 members
GMAT Score:800

by [email protected] » Fri Dec 02, 2016 9:29 pm
gocoder wrote:I can't see why the the author is not supporting the privatization of transport.
What is flaw in E here ? Please help.
Getting the right answers to GMAT Reading Comprehension questions requires giving the questions a certain respect. This is not elementary school Reading Comprehension. This is advanced Reading Comprehension, and you have to read the questions carefully and be very careful in choosing answers.

In this case, a careful reading reveals that the question is not about what the author is doing in general.

The question is asking why the author put quotation marks around the word "privatization."

If the question were, "Why did the author use a comma after the word 'controversial?'" or "Why did the writer use capitals in writing 'Essential Air Service'?" would you answer, "To support his view"?

Everything the author does is in a sense to support his view, but within that overall scheme, the specific purpose of the quotes around the word "privatization" is to emphasize that the privatization of the airlines is not quite a complete privatization.
Marty Murray
Chief Curriculum and Content Architect
[email protected]


See why Target Test Prep is rated 5 out of 5 stars on Beat the GMAT. Read our reviews.