A batch of cookies was divided among three tins: 2/3 of all the cookies were placed in either the blue tin or the green tin, and the rest were placed in the red tin. If 1/4 of all the cookies were placed in the blue tin, what fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other tins were placed in the green tin?

(A) 15/2

(B) 9/4

(C) 5/9

(D) 7/5

(E) 9/7

OA: C

## Error in Kaplan 800 - Word Problem # 5

##### This topic has expert replies

- bml1105
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
**Posts:**113**Joined:**24 Nov 2013**Thanked**: 1 times**Followed by:**5 members

(# of cookies in green tin)/{(# of cookies in green tin)+(# of cookies in red tin)}

Why would the number of cookies in the green tin be in the denominator? Shouldn't it be the # of cookies in the blue tin + the # of cookies in the red tin, since the question asks "what fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other tins were placed in the green tin"

### GMAT/MBA Expert

- [email protected]
- GMAT Instructor
**Posts:**15946**Joined:**08 Dec 2008**Location:**Vancouver, BC**Thanked**: 5254 times**Followed by:**1267 members**GMAT Score:**770

Let's start with a certain number of cookies that works well with all of the fractions.bml1105 wrote:A batch of cookies was divided among three tins: 2/3 of all the cookies were placed in either the blue tin or the green tin, and the rest were placed in the red tin. If 1/4 of all the cookies were placed in the blue tin, what fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other tins were placed in the green tin?

(A) 15/2

(B) 9/4

(C) 5/9

(D) 7/5

(E) 9/7

OA: C

Let's say that there are

**36**cookies altogether.

*2/3 of all the cookies were placed in either the blue tin or the green tin*So, 24 cookies were placed in either the blue tin or the green tin

*The rest were placed in the red tin*So, 12 cookies were placed in the red tin

*1/4 of***all**the cookies were placed in the blue tinSo, 9 cookies were placed in the blue tin

So, the number of cookies that were placed in the green tin =

**36**- 12 - 9 =

**15**

*If 1/4 of all the cookies were placed in the blue tin,*

**what fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other (non blue) tins were placed in the green tin?**There are 27 cookies in the non-blue tins.

15 of them are in the green tin

Fraction = 15/27 = [spoiler]5/9[/spoiler]

Answer: C

Cheers,

Brent

### GMAT/MBA Expert

- [email protected]
- Elite Legendary Member
**Posts:**10392**Joined:**23 Jun 2013**Location:**Palo Alto, CA**Thanked**: 2867 times**Followed by:**510 members**GMAT Score:**800

Are these answer choices formatted correctly? I agree with Brent's approach (TESTing VALUES works really well on this question), but these answers, as written, imply that the only possible answer is the correct one.

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,

Rich

- theCodeToGMAT
- Legendary Member
**Posts:**1556**Joined:**14 Aug 2012**Thanked**: 448 times**Followed by:**34 members**GMAT Score:**650

B/G = 2/3 * C

R = 1/3 * C

B = 1/4 * C

Let Cookies be 60

B/G = 40

R = 20

B = 15

So, G = 25

Fraction: 25/45 = 5/9

R = 1/3 * C

B = 1/4 * C

Let Cookies be 60

B/G = 40

R = 20

B = 15

So, G = 25

Fraction: 25/45 = 5/9

R A H U L

- bml1105
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
**Posts:**113**Joined:**24 Nov 2013**Thanked**: 1 times**Followed by:**5 members

I was reading the question as what fraction of cookies is in green compared to the cookies in blue and red OR (# in green tin)/[(# in red tin) + (# in blue tin)] and wondering why I was getting it wrong.

- GMATGuruNY
- GMAT Instructor
**Posts:**15533**Joined:**25 May 2010**Location:**New York, NY**Thanked**: 13060 times**Followed by:**1901 members**GMAT Score:**790

Let the total number of cookies = the LCM of the two denominators in the prompt = 12bml1105 wrote: ↑Thu May 29, 2014 4:49 pmA batch of cookies was divided among three tins: 2/3 of all the cookies were placed in either the blue tin or the green tin, and the rest were placed in the red tin. If 1/4 of all the cookies were placed in the blue tin, what fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other tins were placed in the green tin?

(A) 15/2

(B) 9/4

(C) 5/9

(D) 7/5

(E) 9/7

Since 2/3 of the cookies are placed in the blue or green tin, B+G = 2/3* 12 = 8

Since 1/4 of the cookies are placed in the blue tin, B = 1/4 * 12 = 3

*What fraction of the cookies that were placed in the other tins were placed in the green tin?*

other tins = total - B = 12-3 = 9

G = (B+G) - B = 8-3 = 5

green/other = 5/9

The correct answer is C.

Mitch Hunt

Private Tutor for the GMAT and GRE

[email protected]

If you find one of my posts helpful, please take a moment to click on the "UPVOTE" icon.

Available for tutoring in NYC and long-distance.

For more information, please email me at [email protected].

Student Review #1

Student Review #2

Student Review #3

Private Tutor for the GMAT and GRE

[email protected]

If you find one of my posts helpful, please take a moment to click on the "UPVOTE" icon.

Available for tutoring in NYC and long-distance.

For more information, please email me at [email protected].

Student Review #1

Student Review #2

Student Review #3