Q.) Is x<y
I) (1/x)<(1/y)
II) (x/y)<0
Someone pls explain.
Inequalities
This topic has expert replies

 Senior  Next Rank: 100 Posts
 Posts: 97
 Joined: 01 Sep 2010
 Thanked: 1 times
 Followed by:2 members
to me the answer is C here
is y>x
(1) (1/y)>(1/x)
(1/y)(1/x)>0
(xy)/(xy)>0
here two cases are possible
x>y and xy>0 or
x<y and xy<0
so if we can prove that xy<0 it cames that y>x
but 1 st is insuff
(2)x/y<0, from here we can`t estimate what is greater, so insuff, but we have one important point
x and y have opposite signs, is x is +ve then y is ve and is x is ve then y+ve
both from 2 st we know that xy<0 and as xy<0 then y>x
so suff
is y>x
(1) (1/y)>(1/x)
(1/y)(1/x)>0
(xy)/(xy)>0
here two cases are possible
x>y and xy>0 or
x<y and xy<0
so if we can prove that xy<0 it cames that y>x
but 1 st is insuff
(2)x/y<0, from here we can`t estimate what is greater, so insuff, but we have one important point
x and y have opposite signs, is x is +ve then y is ve and is x is ve then y+ve
both from 2 st we know that xy<0 and as xy<0 then y>x
so suff
 Tani
 Legendary Member
 Posts: 1255
 Joined: 07 Nov 2008
 Location: St. Louis
 Thanked: 312 times
 Followed by:90 members
Given: (1/y)>(1/x)
Multiply by x
a) if x is positive, you get x/y>1. Both must be positive and x must be greater than y
b) if x is negative you get x/y<1. that gives us two cases:
b1)If y is positive and x is negative, we have a negative number less than +1 and don't have any idea which is greater.
b2)If y is negative, we have a positive number and the absolute value of x must be less than the absolute value of y, but since both are negative that means the actual value of x is greater. Insufficient.
The second clue alone is insufficient since all it tells us is that x and y have the same sign.
Putting them together, if x and y are both positive (case a), we have shown x is greater than y.
Also, if x and y are both negative (case b2) we have also shown x is greater than y.
The answer is C.
If the algebra isn't working for you, try picking numbers.
Multiply by x
a) if x is positive, you get x/y>1. Both must be positive and x must be greater than y
b) if x is negative you get x/y<1. that gives us two cases:
b1)If y is positive and x is negative, we have a negative number less than +1 and don't have any idea which is greater.
b2)If y is negative, we have a positive number and the absolute value of x must be less than the absolute value of y, but since both are negative that means the actual value of x is greater. Insufficient.
The second clue alone is insufficient since all it tells us is that x and y have the same sign.
Putting them together, if x and y are both positive (case a), we have shown x is greater than y.
Also, if x and y are both negative (case b2) we have also shown x is greater than y.
The answer is C.
If the algebra isn't working for you, try picking numbers.
Tani Wolff
GMAT/MBA Expert
 Ian Stewart
 GMAT Instructor
 Posts: 2612
 Joined: 02 Jun 2008
 Location: Toronto
 Thanked: 1090 times
 Followed by:355 members
 GMAT Score:780
Statement 1 will be true whenever x is negative and y is positive, in which case x < y. But Statement 1 is also true if x > y > 0 (take x = 3, y = 2, for example). So not sufficient.akshatgupta87 wrote:Q.) Is x<y
I) (1/x)<(1/y)
II) (x/y)<0
Someone pls explain.
Statement 2 tells us that one of x or y is negative, the other positive, but we don't know which. Not sufficient.
Together, we know from Statement 2 that one of x or y is negative, the other positive. Statement 1 can then only be true if x is negative and y is positive, in which case certainly x < y (negative numbers are always smaller than positive numbers), so together the two Statements are sufficient. C.
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com