Reading Comprehension

Milankovitch proposed in the early twentieth century
that the ice ages were caused by variations in the Earth's
orbit around the Sun. For sometime this theory was
considered untestable, largely because there was no suffi-
(5) ciently precise chronology of the ice ages with which
the orbital variations could be matched.
To establish such a chronology it is necessary to
determine the relative amounts of land ice that existed
at various times in the Earth's past. A recent discovery
(10) makes such a determination possible: relative land-ice
volume for a given period can be deduced from the ratio
of two oxygen isotopes, 16 and 18, found in ocean sedi-
ments. Almost all the oxygen in water is oxygen 16, but
a few molecules out of every thousand incorporate the
(15) heavier isotope 18.
When an ice age begins, the continental ice sheets grow,
steadily reducing the amount of water evaporated from the ocean that will eventually
return to it. Because heavier isotopes tend to be left
behid when water evaporates from the ocean surfaces,
(20) the remaining ocean water becomes progressively
enriched in oxygen 18. The degree of enrichment can
be determined by analyzing ocean sediments of the
period, because these sediments are composed of calcium
carbonate shells of marine organisms, shells that were
(25) constructed with oxygen atoms drawn from the sur-
rounding ocean. The higher the ratio of oxygen 18 to
oxygen 16 in a sedimentary specimen, the more land ice
there was when the sediment was laid down.
As an indicator of shifts in the Earth's climate, the
(30) isotope record has two advantages. First, it is a global
record: there is remarkably little variation in isotope
ratios in sedimentary specimens taken from different
continental locations. Second, it is a more continuous
record than that taken from rocks on land. Because of
(35) these advantages, sedimentary evidence can be dated
with sufficient accuracy by radiometric methods to
establish a precise chronology of the ice ages. The dated
isotope record shows that the fluctuations in global
ice volume over the past several hundred thousand years
(40) have a pattern: an ice age occurs roughly once every
100,000 years. These data have established a strong
connection between variations in the Earth's orbit and
the periodicity of the ice ages.

However, it is important to note that other factors,
(45) such as volcanic particulates or variations in the amount
of sunlight received by the Earth, could potentially have
affected the climate. The advantage of the Milankovitch
theory is that it is testable: changes in the Earth's orbit
can be calculated and dated by applying Newton's laws
(50) of gravity to progressively earlier configurations of the
bodies in the solar system. Yet the lack of information
about other possible factors affecting global climate does
not make them unimportant.

49. In the passage, the author is primarily interested in
(A) suggesting an alternative to an outdated research method.
(B) introducing a new research method that calls an accepted theory into question
(C) emphasizing the instability of data gathered from the application of a new scientific method
(D) presenting a theory and describing a new method to test that theory
(E) initiating a debate about a widely accepted theory

[spoiler]OA: D[/spoiler]

I have realized that at the very beginning the theory was that the ice age was due to the changes in earth orbit. This theory was untestable. Later there came some techniques to test the theory. Finally the author of the passage states that there are other factors, though not testable, that are determinants of ice ages.

Finally the author concluded with a debate over the theory that the ice age was due to the changes in the earth orbit.

What do the experts think?

Please explain.

Thanks.

The author begins by stating a theory and the reasons why it couldn't be tested earlier. He then devotes the majority of the passage on how a new methodology has successfully tested this theory. In the end, he remarks, that other theories may also be correct but are untestable as yet. Thus D should be correct.

E is not correct because, had the author's intention been to initiate a debate on this new theory, he would have pointed out some of the constraints of the theory. On the contrary, the author begins with a problem with the theory (its testability) and goes on to resolve that problem. Moreover, it is not mentioned anywhere in the passage that the Milankovitch theory is widely acceptable.