GMATPrep - Marbles

badri077 · Posted: Sun Sep 16, 2007 1:28 am Post subject: GMATPrep - Marbles

A question from GMATPrep.

A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles, and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater than the probability that the marble chosen will be white ?

1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r)
2) b-w >r

I'll post the answer after a few repplies.
Hope one of you can help me out here.

Thnx,
-B

samirpandeyit62 · Posted: Sun Sep 16, 2007 2:15 am Post subject:

Answer should be A

Q asks "is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater than the probability that the marble chosen will be white ? "

this is possible only if r>w

stm1 :
r/(b+w) > w/(b+r)

i.e. r(b + r) > w (b + w)

now since b is same(constant) in both expressions so r>w to make the expression true

hence SUFF

stmt 2: b-w >r
this would be possible for both the cases r>w & w>r

i.e b =20 ,w =14 ,r =5

& b=10, w =2 & r = 6

so Insuff

badri077 · Posted: Sun Sep 16, 2007 9:52 am Post subject: Re:

Thanks.
The Ans is A.

So is brute force substitution the thumb for most such problems ? I was pretty pressed for time, tried a few values and couldn't get it right and moved on..

-B

saurabh_1922@yahoo.co.in · Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 4:29 pm Post subject:

I did this way:
the prob of taking red ball out = r/b+w+r
for white ball = w/b+w+r
the question is whether r/b+w+r > w/b+w+r
or we have to find whether r > w
According to 1
r/(b+w) > w/(b+r)
Add 1 to both sides
this makes r+b+w/b+w>r+b+w/b+r
this givesb+r > b+w which means r > w SUFF
2.b - w > r
here we don't know if w>r or w<r
hence A

badri077 · Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 9:05 pm Post subject: thanks

nice trick! Thanks for the explanation!

-B

karthick451 · Posted: Fri Sep 21, 2007 7:09 am Post subject:

one more shot,

we need to prove

r/(r+b+w) > b/(r+b+w)

cross multiplying

= r^2 + br+wr > wr+bw+w^2
= r^2+br > bw+ w^2
= r/(b+w) > w/(b+r)

which is the given first condition
hence A is suff.

b is not suff because, b>r+w is given, but it doesnt say anything about r and w.