Beat The GMAT - the MBA Social Network

 
  • Home
  • Forums
    • Forum Home Page
    • Featured Experts
    • I just Beat The GMAT!
    • Admissions Success Stories
    • GMAT Strategy
    • GMAT Math
      • Problem Solving
      • Data Sufficiency
    • GMAT Verbal and Essays
      • Sentence Correction
      • Critical Reasoning
      • Reading Comprehension
      • GMAT Essays (AWA)
    • Business School
      • Research MBA Programs
      • The MBA Application Process
      • MBA Student Life
    • RSS Feeds
  • Self Study
    • GMAT Library
    • Getting Started
      • Getting Started on Beat The GMAT
      • Intro to GMAT
    • Study Plans
      • The 60-Day GMAT Study Guide
      • Custom GMAT Study Plans
      • 700+ GMAT Student Stories
      • How to Develop a Study Plan
      • 3-Month GMAT Study Plan
      • 1-Month GMAT Study Plan
      • Verbal-Focus GMAT Study Plan
      • 2-Week GMAT Study Plan
      • Retaking the GMAT Plan
      • 3-Month TOEFL Study Plan
      • The Best 'How-To' Study List
    • Books
    • Resource Links
    • Practice
      • Daily GMAT Math Question
      • Daily GMAT Verbal Question
      • Free GMAT Flashcards
      • GMAT Error Logs and Tracking
    • Inspiration
      • I just Beat The GMAT! Success Stories
      • The Beat The GMAT Scholarship
        • 2012 Beat The GMAT Scholarship
        • Beat The GMAT Scholarship Alumni
  • GMAT Courses
    • Verified GMAT Course Reviews
    • GMAT Course Discounts
    • Economist GMAT
      • Economist GMAT Course Reviews
      • Economist GMAT Discounts
      • About Economist GMAT
    • GMAT Prep Now
      • GMAT Prep Now Discounts
      • About GMAT Prep Now
    • Kaplan
      • Kaplan Course Reviews
      • Kaplan GMAT Discounts
      • About Kaplan
    • Knewton
      • Knewton Course Reviews
      • Knewton GMAT Discounts
      • About Knewton
    • Manhattan GMAT
      • Manhattan GMAT Course Reviews
      • Manhattan GMAT Discounts
      • About Manhattan GMAT
    • The Princeton Review
      • The Princeton Review Course Reviews
      • The Princeton Review GMAT Discounts
      • About The Princeton Review
    • Veritas Prep
      • Veritas Prep Course Reviews
      • Veritas Prep GMAT Discounts
      • About Veritas Prep
  • MBA Application
    • MBA Watch
    • MBA Admissions Library
    • MBA Admissions Course
    • Expert Profile Evaluations
    • MBA Essay Breakdowns
      • 2012-2013 Top B-School Essays
      • Berkeley Haas Essays
      • Chicago Booth Essays
      • Columbia Business School Essays
      • Dartmouth Tuck Essays
      • Harvard Business School Essays
      • INSEAD Application Essays
      • Kellogg Essays
      • MIT Sloan Essays
      • Stanford GSB Essays
      • Wharton Essays
    • Research MBA Programs
      • Research MBA Programs Forum
      • School Selection
      • Business School Trends
      • International
    • The MBA Application Process
      • The MBA Application Process Forum
      • Resume
      • Business School Essays
      • Recommendations
      • Interview
      • Waitlist
      • Financial Aid
    • MBA Student Life
      • MBA Student Life Forum
      • MBA Student Life Articles
  • Blogs
    • All GMAT and MBA Blogs
    • Pre-MBA Blogs
    • MBA Student Blogs
    • Business School Blogs
    • GMAT Company Blogs
    • GMAT Tutor Blogs
    • Admissions Consultant Blogs
    • How to Add Your Blog
  • Products
    • GMAT & MBA Marketplace
    • MBA Admissions Course
    • Essay Writing Course
    • Free GMAT Flashcards
    • The 60-Day GMAT Study Guide
    • Daily GMAT Math Question
    • Daily GMAT Verbal Question
    • GMAT Error Logs and Tracking
  • MBA Watch
  • The GMAT/MBA Library
  • GMAT Discounts
  • GMAT Course Reviews
  • MBA Admissions Course

Logic Over Content – How Not To Be Misled By Difficult Wording in RC Questions

by Economist GMAT Tutor on November 18th, 2012
14 comments
Click here to learn more about The Economist GMAT Tutor and its products & services.
Posted in
  • Business Passage
  • Critical Reasoning
  • Evaluate the Argument
  • GMAT Verbal
  • Long RC Passage
  • Main Point
  • Method of Reasoning
  • Reading Comprehension
  • Science Passage
  • Short RC Passage

It would probably not come as a great shock for you to find that, just like other GMAT question types, Reading Comprehension questions have their own way of sidetracking us. One such strategy is making the test-takers focus on the content of the passage rather than concentrate on its LOGIC and STRUCTURE. If we approach GMAT reading passages the same way we tackle other texts – that is, reading all of them and trying to understand them – we both lose time and lower our chances of answering questions correctly. Since GMAT reading passages are taken from a wide variety of scientific disciplines, the chances of understanding the content of each of these excerpts in depth are slim.

Actually, Reading Comprehension questions try to establish whether we can quickly (1) analyze  the structure of a passage, (2) get the gist of it, and (3) extract specific information from it. So by reading the entire passage and struggling with unfamiliar, often technical terms, we actually can be easily misled and end up choosing an incorrect answer. However, there are a few methods that test-takers can use in order to avoid being distracted by content of the text. Let me present them.

Firstly, we should focus on the structure and function of each sentence rather than on the information it presents.

To make this clearer, let’s look at the following example:

Originally, scientists speculated that Mars may have liquid water on its surface. The basis for this theory was changes in light and dark areas in the polar regions seen even by the most primitive telescopes, which were attributed to seas and continents.

Now let’s try to extract the structural information presented by this paragraph. What do you think is the main theme of this short text? Well…Does it speak about Mars and the existence of water on its surface? If that was your answer, you were misled by the wording and fell for the trap. Let’s try to select the words that point to the structure of the paragraph: “ORIGINALLY,… The basis for this theory …” Having extracted the structure words we can see that the paragraph in fact speaks about what scientists thought at first = ORIGINALLY. In this case, the word “originally” is a major hint. In other cases, it could be expressions such as “however,”" for example,”" therefore,” etc. These words provide structural information about the relation of the sentence/paragraph in which they appear to the previous sentence or paragraph.

Unfortunately the problem is not only related to structure words. We can also get misled by the meaning of words used in an RC passage. The same idea can be presented in many different ways using various expressions. Let’s consider a simple example:

“John is a vegetarian.” Is there any other way that we could convey the same meaning in other words? How about: “John does not eat meat.” ? The wording used in RC passages is often much more difficult in comparison with the example above and can be a serious obstacle on our path to the correct answer. Therefore, to make sure that we don’t get confused we should rephrase the difficult parts of the paragraph in simpler terms.

Yet another trap can be waiting for test-takers among answer choices that will use the  wording different than the one used in the passage to express the same meaning and vice versa – use similar wording to express a different meaning.

It’s essential that we avoid automatically choosing answer choices just because they use the same words that appeared in the passage. Instead, we should adhere to the idea that’s expressed in the text, bearing in mind that the correct answer could express that same idea using other words.

Key take-aways:

  1. Focus on logic, structure and function rather than on content (the information that’s in it).
  2. Focus on meaning of expressions rather than on their wording.

Sigining off, I am leaving you with an interesting question to solve. I will provide the answer in the coming days:

The overarching implications of discursive constructivism are realized in every aspect of reality in which language is involved, since language manifests our conceptual framework. Because something is the way it is because we bestow our perceptions onto it via language, examining the philosophy of language proves itself especially important in feminist discourse. Some feminists have advanced the notion of formulating a new reality more congenial to women by which women will liberate themselves from oppressive patriarchal discourses and thrive with their new found expressive capabilities.

The inherent maleness of language, in light of discursive constructivism, traps women in a hierarchy of patriarchal social relations in which they are delegated to the lower rungs. Language often represents maleness as the norm, obscures the existence and importance of women, and imbeds a male-centric worldview, creating a picture of the world more suited to men than women. The English language, among many others, engages in what Frye calls the absurd practice of sex-marking, in which language assigns a critical importance to gender in situations in which it is, in reality, irrelevant, thereby perpetuating the narrative that men and women are somehow irrevocably and fundamentally dissimilar.

The patriarchal nature of language cannot be denied as a general force, yet feminists are not entirely correct to say that the entirety of a language enforces a discriminatory narrative. Although a plethora of specific terms and usages which stifle women’s equality exist, certain neutral words are undeniably present which have escaped the male bias which afflicts so much of our semantic reality. It is important to note that the patriarchal structure of society does not grant men complete control over language, despite their immense influence in the creation of dictionaries, grammatical rules and usage guides.

Which of the following best summarizes the contents of the passage?

A. Since many linguistic constructs display no gender bias, the feminist argument that language creates the male-centric structure of our society that traps women in the lower rungs of a patriarchal hierarchy has no merit.

B. Feminists consider language, which, they argue, has a male bias and therefore devalues women, to be of great importance because of language’s effect on how we perceive reality, even though this critique, although correct in principle, is unfounded in some cases.

C. The feminist argument that language reflects the patriarchal order of society and therefore relegates women to a lower status has many merits but it is not entirely correct.

D. Discursive constructivism, the concept that language is an active agent in the creation of what we perceive as reality, is of great concern to feminists, but their concerns, while founded, are exaggerated.

E. Language imposes a patriarchal discourse biased against women and constitutes a grave concern to feminists, who, although aware of language as a force which shapes reality, believe it is only male-centric in certain aspects.

If you liked this article, let Economist GMAT Tutor know by clicking Like.

RELATED ARTICLES

14 comments

  • Ankit on November 17th, 2012 at 9:41 pm

    I would go with C.

    Reply to this comment
  • Deepthi on November 18th, 2012 at 10:20 pm

    Between B and E, il go with B.

    Reply to this comment
    • Sally on November 19th, 2012 at 4:11 am

      I will go with E

  • mari on November 19th, 2012 at 11:29 am

    I'd say B!

    Reply to this comment
  • Megs on November 19th, 2012 at 9:27 pm

    B looks correct to me.

    Reply to this comment
  • Dong Bin on November 20th, 2012 at 9:32 am

    I perfer D

    Reply to this comment
  • Sameer Khandelwal on November 20th, 2012 at 2:38 pm

    Torn between B and C, but I'd go with B.

    Reply to this comment
  • vikram on November 20th, 2012 at 6:45 pm

    imo C. B gives detail - "unfound in some cases" but what does that imply ? C tells that "not entirely correct". hence C

    Reply to this comment
  • Asif on November 20th, 2012 at 7:02 pm

    D for me

    Reply to this comment
  • nsk on November 21st, 2012 at 3:00 am

    Between B and E , i would go for B

    Reply to this comment
  • Nitin Agarwal on November 21st, 2012 at 3:20 am

    I am confused between B and E, after breaking my head through the passage and the options. I would like to go with B.

    error in E: because feminist don't believe that it is male centric in certain aspects.
    This line proves this "yet feminists are not entirely correct to say that the entirety of a language enforces a discriminatory narrative"

    Reply to this comment
  • Milan on November 22nd, 2012 at 9:09 am

    Hi,

    I used OCTAVE method:
    Opinion: Autho
    r is concerned about Female but he is helpless in some aspects, In other words. "Language imposes a patriarchal discourse biased against women and constitutes a grave concern to feminists, who, although aware of language as a force which shapes reality, believe it is only male-centric in certain aspects."

    Tone: Evaluating, since it has + ve and -ve points in favour of female.

    According to me it is E.

    PS:Please correct me if my analysis is wrong.

    Reply to this comment
    • Kasia on November 26th, 2012 at 2:39 am

      Thank you for the very fruitful and interesting discussion. You can read the explanation of this question here:
      http://www.beatthegmat.com/logic-over-content-t146641.html#535040

  • Kasia on November 26th, 2012 at 2:40 am

    Kasia on November 26th, 2012 at 2:39 am
    Thank you for the very fruitful and interesting discussion. You can read the explanation of this question here:
    http://www.beatthegmat.com/logic-over-content-t146641.html#535040

    Reply to this comment

Ask a Question or Leave a Reply

The author Economist GMAT Tutor gets email notifications for all questions or replies to this post.

Guidelines:

Some HTML allowed. Keep your comments above the belt or risk having them deleted. Signup for a Gravatar to have your pictures show up by your comment.

Click here to cancel reply.

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

  • FREE
    GMAT Prep Now Videos and OG13 Improvement Chart
  • FREE
    Kaplan GMAT Practice Test
  • FREE
    Knewton GMAT Challenge Videos
  • FREE
    Manhattan GMAT’s Free Guide To Getting Started With the GMAT
  • FREE
    Free 7-Day Trial with The Economist GMAT Tutor (full access)
  • FREE
    Princeton Review Practice GMAT
  • FREE
    Veritas Prep Free 7-Day Trial - GMAT On Demand

GMAT PREP DISCOUNTS

  • $139 only
    GMAT Prep Now Full Video Course
  • SAVE $150
    Select Kaplan GMAT Courses & Tutoring Services
  • $101 OFF
    Knewton GMAT Complete Prep (5 days only)
  • SAVE $210
    Manhattan GMAT Courses and Services
  • $75 OFF
    The Economist GMAT Tutor
  • 10% OFF
    The Princeton Review GMAT Courses
  • SAVE $770
    Veritas Prep GMAT Courses and Consulting Packages

All GMAT/MBA Articles

  • GMAT AWA Essays (57)
    • Analysis of Argument (29)
    • Analysis of Issue (20)
  • GMAT Horror Stories (1)
  • GMAT Integrated Reasoning (85)
    • Graphics Interpretation (8)
    • Multi-Source Reasoning (7)
    • Table Analysis (10)
    • Two-Part Analysis (10)
  • GMAT Math (758)
    • Algebra (165)
    • Arithmetic (217)
    • Data Sufficiency (260)
    • Geometry (95)
    • Number Properties (121)
    • Permutations/Combinations (27)
    • Probability (53)
    • Problem Solving (279)
    • Statistics (21)
    • Translation (1)
    • Word Problems (124)
  • GMAT Success Stories (59)
    • 600-700 Score (1)
    • 700-800 Score (54)
  • GMAT Test Prep (534)
    • Retake (45)
    • Strategy (399)
    • Stress Management (100)
    • Study Plan (159)
    • Timing (95)
  • GMAT Verbal (679)
    • Critical Reasoning (219)
    • Reading Comprehension (130)
    • Sentence Correction (350)
  • MBA Admissions (2311)
    • Admissions Consulting (613)
    • Essays (678)
    • Extracurriculars (110)
    • GMAT (335)
    • GPA (143)
    • GRE (31)
    • International Admissions (65)
    • Interviews (202)
    • MBA Fairs (37)
    • Rankings (81)
    • Recommendation Letters (165)
    • Resume (121)
    • School Selection (59)
    • School Visits (190)
    • Trends (475)
    • Waitlist (49)
    • Work Experience (219)
  • MBA and Beyond (2538)
    • Career (1592)
    • Clubs (52)
    • Financial Aid (125)
    • Recruiting (208)
    • Student Life (1197)
  • MBA News (167)
  • Videos (590)

FREE UPCOMING GMAT EVENTS

  • June 19
    Free Manhattan GMAT LiveOnline Trial Class
  • June 25
    Free Veritas Prep - Online GMAT Prep Seminar
  • July 9
    Free Kaplan GMAT Preview Class - GMAT Challenge

Follow Us

  • RSS
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Beat The GMAT on Facebook

POPULAR RESOURCES

  • MBA Watch
  • MBA Admissions Video Course
  • The GMAT/MBA Library
  • 60-Day GMAT Study Guide
  • GMAT Flashcards
  • GMAT Error Logs
  • GMAT Forums

COURSE LOCATIONS

  • New York GMAT Courses
  • Los Angeles GMAT Courses
  • San Francisco GMAT Courses
  • Boston GMAT Courses
  • Chicago GMAT Courses
  • Houston GMAT Courses
  • Philadelphia GMAT Courses
  • San Diego GMAT Courses
  • Washington D.C. GMAT Courses
  • Dallas GMAT Courses

COURSE REVIEWS

  • GMAT Course Reviews
  • GMAT Tutor from The Economist
  • Grockit GMAT Reviews
  • Kaplan GMAT Reviews
  • Knewton GMAT Reviews
  • Manhattan GMAT Reviews
  • Princeton Review GMAT Reviews
  • Veritas Prep GMAT Reviews
  • About
  • Press
  • Community Rules
© Hobsons, Inc. All rights reserved. Please read our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy