Hello all
Please help me with an even odd problem.
If a,b,c are integers and ab + c is odd. Which of the following must be true?
1. a+c is odd
2. b+c is odd
3. abc is even
My challenge here is not the problem itself but the timing. I have figured out the problem by drawing a table and and testing with brute force but it took me good 4 - 5 minutes. Is there a smarter way to figure out the problem in under 2 minutes.
Appreciate your help!
5-Day Free Trial
5-day free, full-access trial TTP
Available with Beat the GMAT members only code
MORE DETAILS
Even Odd Problem
This topic has expert replies
GMAT/MBA Expert
-
[email protected]
- Elite Legendary Member
- Posts: 10392
- Joined: Sun Jun 23, 2013 6:38 pm
- Location: Palo Alto, CA
- Thanked: 2867 times
- Followed by:511 members
- GMAT Score:800
Hi melguy,
You're essentially responsible to check 4 possible situations, so it's not clear how you spent 4-5 minutes on this prompt. Maybe you TESTED difficult values or perhaps you need to work on your organization.. You might find it helpful to use the built-in Number Properties to your advantage though.
To start, we know that A, B and C are all INTEGERS and (A)(B) + C = ODD.
That equation is the sum of two values - to end in an ODD sum, one of the 'parts' must be EVEN and the other must be ODD. Thus, we could have...
(A)(B) = even and C = odd
(A)(B) = odd and C = even
Breaking this down further, in the first situation...
1st option A = even, B = even, C = odd
2nd option A = even, B = odd, C = odd
3rd option A = odd, B = even, C = odd
In the second situation...
4th option A = odd, B = odd, C = odd
However, the prompt tells us that (A)(B) + C = ODD, so this 4th option is NOT allowed.
We're asked which of the Roman Numerals are true. Since you have not listed the 5 answer choices, we're forced to check all 3.
1. A+C is odd
Not in the 3rd option.
2. B+C is odd
Not in the 2nd option.
3. ABC is even
In all 3 of the permutable options, ABC IS even, so Roman Numeral 3 is always true.
GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich
You're essentially responsible to check 4 possible situations, so it's not clear how you spent 4-5 minutes on this prompt. Maybe you TESTED difficult values or perhaps you need to work on your organization.. You might find it helpful to use the built-in Number Properties to your advantage though.
To start, we know that A, B and C are all INTEGERS and (A)(B) + C = ODD.
That equation is the sum of two values - to end in an ODD sum, one of the 'parts' must be EVEN and the other must be ODD. Thus, we could have...
(A)(B) = even and C = odd
(A)(B) = odd and C = even
Breaking this down further, in the first situation...
1st option A = even, B = even, C = odd
2nd option A = even, B = odd, C = odd
3rd option A = odd, B = even, C = odd
In the second situation...
4th option A = odd, B = odd, C = odd
However, the prompt tells us that (A)(B) + C = ODD, so this 4th option is NOT allowed.
We're asked which of the Roman Numerals are true. Since you have not listed the 5 answer choices, we're forced to check all 3.
1. A+C is odd
Not in the 3rd option.
2. B+C is odd
Not in the 2nd option.
3. ABC is even
In all 3 of the permutable options, ABC IS even, so Roman Numeral 3 is always true.
GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich
Last edited by [email protected] on Sun Oct 23, 2016 5:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
fiza gupta
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:55 pm
- Location: Punjab
- Thanked: 31 times
- Followed by:7 members
ab + c = odd => even(e) + odd(o) = odd
one has to be even and one odd from ab and c
(i) ab = odd , c = even
ab to be odd both has to be odd
so we get a = odd , b = odd and c = even - (i)
(ii) ab = even , c =odd
ab = even => either even or both
a = even b = even c odd -(ii)
b = even a = odd c = odd - (iii)
a = even b = odd c = odd -(iv)
a+c is odd
(iii) conditions will make it false
2. b+c is odd
first three conditions will make it false
3. abc is even
always true in all above options
or we can do it directly
because ab + c = odd
either has to be even and product will be always even.
one has to be even and one odd from ab and c
(i) ab = odd , c = even
ab to be odd both has to be odd
so we get a = odd , b = odd and c = even - (i)
(ii) ab = even , c =odd
ab = even => either even or both
a = even b = even c odd -(ii)
b = even a = odd c = odd - (iii)
a = even b = odd c = odd -(iv)
a+c is odd
(iii) conditions will make it false
2. b+c is odd
first three conditions will make it false
3. abc is even
always true in all above options
or we can do it directly
because ab + c = odd
either has to be even and product will be always even.
Fiza Gupta
-
fiza gupta
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:55 pm
- Location: Punjab
- Thanked: 31 times
- Followed by:7 members
in 4th option : a = odd , b odd and c= oddTo start, we know that A, B and C are all INTEGERS and (A)(B) + C = ODD.
That equation is the sum of two values - to end in an ODD sum, one of the 'parts' must be EVEN and the other must be ODD. Thus, we could have...
(A)(B) = even and C = odd
(A)(B) = odd and C = even
Breaking this down further, in the first situation...
1st option A = even, B = even, C = odd
2nd option A = even, B = odd, C = odd
3rd option A = odd, B = even, C = odd
In the second situation...
4th option A = odd, B = odd, C = odd
We're asked which of the Roman Numerals are true. Since you have not listed the 5 answer choices, we're forced to check all 3.
1. A+C is odd
Not in the 3rd or 4th options.
2. B+C is odd
Not in the 2nd or 4th option.
3. ABC is even
Not in the 4th option
Thus, NONE of the Roman Numerals is always true.
ab + c = will be even because odd*odd = odd
odd +odd = even
Fiza Gupta
GMAT/MBA Expert
-
[email protected]
- Elite Legendary Member
- Posts: 10392
- Joined: Sun Jun 23, 2013 6:38 pm
- Location: Palo Alto, CA
- Thanked: 2867 times
- Followed by:511 members
- GMAT Score:800
Hi fiza gupta,
Good eye. I've updated my solution.
GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich
Good eye. I've updated my solution.
GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich
-
vineet.nitd
- Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Sun Sep 21, 2014 10:25 pm
- Location: India
- Thanked: 3 times
What is the implication of ab + c being odd?
It implies that one of the two components (ab OR c) is even, while the other is odd.
If that is true their product is also going to be even, since one component is even for sure.
Hence, 3 must be true.
Statements 1 and 2 have symmetry as "a" AND "b" could behave in the same way given the original expression. So, we know that either statements 1 and 2 must both be true OR must both be false.
Now let's test statement 1, given ab + c is odd :
If a is even, b is odd, c is odd => Statement 1 is true
If a is odd, b is even, c is odd=> Statement 1 is not true
So, both statements 1 and 2 may or may not be true.
It implies that one of the two components (ab OR c) is even, while the other is odd.
If that is true their product is also going to be even, since one component is even for sure.
Hence, 3 must be true.
Statements 1 and 2 have symmetry as "a" AND "b" could behave in the same way given the original expression. So, we know that either statements 1 and 2 must both be true OR must both be false.
Now let's test statement 1, given ab + c is odd :
If a is even, b is odd, c is odd => Statement 1 is true
If a is odd, b is even, c is odd=> Statement 1 is not true
So, both statements 1 and 2 may or may not be true.
Private GMAT Instructor
----------------------------
Please feel free to connect at [email protected]
----------------------------
Please feel free to connect at [email protected]
GMAT/MBA Expert
-
Brent@GMATPrepNow
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 16207
- Joined: Mon Dec 08, 2008 6:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC
- Thanked: 5254 times
- Followed by:1268 members
- GMAT Score:770
You should be able to test all 8 possible values within 2 minutes. Here we go:melguy wrote: If a,b,c are integers and ab + c is odd. Which of the following must be true?
1. a+c is odd
2. b+c is odd
3. abc is even
A. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
B. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
C. a = EVEN, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is ODD
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is ODD
H. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is EVEN
Since we're told that ab + c is ODD, we can eliminate cases A, B, C and H
Now, let's test the remaining cases.
1. a+c is odd
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case a + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case a + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case a + c is EVEN
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case a + c is ODD
As we can see, a+c NEED NOT be ODD
So, statement 1 is not true
2. b+c is odd
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case b + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case b + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case b + c is ODD
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case b + c is ODD
Great, b+c is always odd.
Statement 2 is true
3. abc is even
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case abc is EVEN
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case abc is EVEN
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case abc is EVEN
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case abc is EVEN
Great, abc is always even
Statement 3 is true
RELATED VIDEO
- Testing Possible Cases: https://www.gmatprepnow.com/module/gmat ... /video/839
Brent Hanneson - Creator of GMATPrepNow.com
eagle eye... and I guess I say that because I literally have problems with my eyesBrent@GMATPrepNow wrote:You should be able to test all 8 possible values within 2 minutes. Here we go:melguy wrote: If a,b,c are integers and ab + c is odd. Which of the following must be true?
1. a+c is odd
2. b+c is odd
3. abc is even
A. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
B. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
C. a = EVEN, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is EVEN
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is ODD
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case ab + c is ODD
H. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = ODD: In this case ab + c is EVEN
Since we're told that ab + c is ODD, we can eliminate cases A, B, C and H
Now, let's test the remaining cases.
1. a+c is odd
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case a + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case a + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case a + c is EVEN
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case a + c is ODD
As we can see, a+c NEED NOT be ODD
So, statement 1 is not true
2. b+c is odd
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case b + c is ODD
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case b + c is ODD
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case b + c is ODD
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case b + c is ODD
Great, b+c is always odd.
Statement 2 is true
3. abc is even
D. a = EVEN, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case abc is EVEN
E. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case abc is EVEN
F. a = ODD, b = EVEN, c = ODD: In this case abc is EVEN
G. a = ODD, b = ODD, c = EVEN: In this case abc is EVEN
Great, abc is always even
Statement 3 is true
RELATED VIDEO
- Testing Possible Cases: https://www.gmatprepnow.com/module/gmat ... /video/839
(tired of Diamox already but what I can do?)
Last edited by Wakenour on Tue Feb 07, 2017 10:06 am, edited 3 times in total.
-
Matt@VeritasPrep
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 2630
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2012 3:32 pm
- Location: East Bay all the way
- Thanked: 625 times
- Followed by:119 members
- GMAT Score:780
I think we're missing an easy approach here.
There's nothing special about a or b: we could just as easily replace one with the other. (For example, ab + c could be 1*2 + 3 or 2*1 + 3.)
From that, we can deduce that either 1 and 2 are BOTH true or BOTH false. Picking a simple set of numbers like my sets above (a = 1, b = 2, c = 3 and a = 2, b = 1, c = 3) lets us this out: they're both false!
From there, we've got III. abc will be even if ANY of a, b, and c are even. Let's see what happens if none of them is even:
a = 1, b = 3, c = 5
But this gives us ab + c = 1*3 + 5 = 8, which isn't odd. (As you can guess, this generalizes to any set of odd numbers: odd*odd + odd = even.)
Since we CAN'T have a, b, c all odd, we must have at least one even, or a * b * c = even.
So III only is true, and we're done!
There's nothing special about a or b: we could just as easily replace one with the other. (For example, ab + c could be 1*2 + 3 or 2*1 + 3.)
From that, we can deduce that either 1 and 2 are BOTH true or BOTH false. Picking a simple set of numbers like my sets above (a = 1, b = 2, c = 3 and a = 2, b = 1, c = 3) lets us this out: they're both false!
From there, we've got III. abc will be even if ANY of a, b, and c are even. Let's see what happens if none of them is even:
a = 1, b = 3, c = 5
But this gives us ab + c = 1*3 + 5 = 8, which isn't odd. (As you can guess, this generalizes to any set of odd numbers: odd*odd + odd = even.)
Since we CAN'T have a, b, c all odd, we must have at least one even, or a * b * c = even.
So III only is true, and we're done!
